Talk:Garden of Assemblage

Possible issues regarding a merge

Should Garden of Assemblage and Cavern of Remembrance be merged into Radiant Garden? In my opinion it's simplest to keep Cavern of Remembrance separate from Radiant Garden and treat it as an optional dungeon (which it is), but I will agree that's not really a strong argument. Cavern of Remembrance and the Garden of Assemblage should definitely be merged I think... were it not for the KH3 version of the area throwing a wrench into it. Thoughts? Merge all? Merge two of them? Merge none? - Joseph Thorn Dalton ^XCV 21:27, 31 May 2023 (UTC)

Definitely merge Cavern of Remembrance and Garden of Assemblage, since we can include the KHIII version like we do the coded data worlds. As per merging with the main Radiant Garden article, while it would be easier to keep it separate (considering too how it was added in KHIIFM), it's also hard to call the Cavern of Remembrance more separated than, say, areas like the Underworld or Christmas Town. So for consistency, merging might be best, but either way would make sense. —Aid1043 (talk) 00:12, 1 June 2023 (UTC)

An argument regarding the points about Christmas Town and the Underworld is that those areas are story relevant and strongly connected to their parent world with a lot of back and forth between the areas, thus making separate story sections for the parent world and the sub-area a nightmare. The Cavern of Remembrance on the other hand is an entirely separate and optional area with no story significance. But even then, merging all three shouldn't be difficult either. The only concern is if a merge would make it harder for people to find the information they're looking for. - Joseph Thorn Dalton ^XCV 11:21, 1 June 2023 (UTC)

I think might be better to keep them separate from the main, only because as JTD points out, I think merging them on the main Radiant Garden might bloat the page up that it'll be harder to find the info of these specific locations that don't hold too much story relevance.--NinjaSheik 01:56, 10 June 2023 (UTC)

I've gone a lot of back and forth on this, but after finishing the Settings and Areas section for Radiant Garden and seeing how it turned out, I honestly see no point in having the separate pages. It's not at all bloated or confusing as I thought it might be. Whatever information any visitor needs can easily be found on the Radiant Garden page now. The tiny bits of story can easily be transferred as well, and the Gameplay section should be moved to either Game:Radiant Garden or the walkthrough, if its even necessary to keep. Thoughts? - Joseph Thorn Dalton ^XCV (talk) 22:01, 28 June 2023 (UTC)

Agreed. The gameplay section for the Cavern of Remembrance is more fitting for the walkthrough, and for the Garden of Assemblage, any info not present yet on how to unlock the battles can be placed on the Organization XIII's Replica Data and Real Organization XIII's Recreated Data pages. The KH2 story is not relevant (and possibly non-canon), and the KH3 story is already covered. TheSilentHero 11:20, 29 June 2023 (UTC)