KHWiki:Traverse Town: Difference between revisions
→Overategorization
| Line 149: | Line 149: | ||
::See alsos can have relations established by category or comment - the relationship is closer than that of these categories. See also sections also invite improvement, while categories on their own don't - the two are not really comparable. It devalues categories to make them simple correlations - X and Y were involved/intertwined in some Z fashion once in the game, so it gets categorized that way? When I think "Radiant Garden" I think "1000 Heartless, the big mace ball heartless, Merlin, Leon, Sephiroth". I certainly don't think "Xaldin". He did nothing but laugh facelessly. [[User:Scottch|Scottch]] 15:40, 30 December 2006 (UTC) | ::See alsos can have relations established by category or comment - the relationship is closer than that of these categories. See also sections also invite improvement, while categories on their own don't - the two are not really comparable. It devalues categories to make them simple correlations - X and Y were involved/intertwined in some Z fashion once in the game, so it gets categorized that way? When I think "Radiant Garden" I think "1000 Heartless, the big mace ball heartless, Merlin, Leon, Sephiroth". I certainly don't think "Xaldin". He did nothing but laugh facelessly. [[User:Scottch|Scottch]] 15:40, 30 December 2006 (UTC) | ||
:::I strongly agree with Scottch, a character should only be in a world's category if that character only is in that world.--[[User:Painocus|Painocus]] | :::I strongly agree with Scottch, a character should only be in a world's category if that character only is in that world.--[[User:Painocus|Painocus]] | ||
::::That's the format I was using. If it is unique to that world, or is heavily focused on that world (i.e. [[Strafer]] being in the Space Paranoids category as opposed to [[Behemoth]] being in the Olympus Coliseum category). Most Heartless, at least, don't belong in any world category, except maybe the Coliseum-only ones, the bosses, and maybe the Invisibles and Angel Stars (I don't know why; I just feel like they deserve being in End of the World's category). Heartless that have a specific theme, though (i.e. Strafers to Space Paranoids or Defenders to Hollow Bastion) ''could'' be in a World category, in my terms.--[[User:Dreyfus2006|Dreyfus]] 01:47, 5 January 2007 (UTC) | ::::That's the format I was using. If it is unique to that world, or is heavily focused on that world (i.e. [[Strafer]] being in the Space Paranoids category as opposed to [[Behemoth]] being in the Olympus Coliseum category). Most Heartless, at least, don't belong in any world category, except maybe the Coliseum-only ones, the bosses, and maybe the Invisibles and Angel Stars (I don't know why; I just feel like they deserve being in End of the World's category). Heartless that have a specific theme, though (i.e. Strafers to Space Paranoids or Defenders to Hollow Bastion) ''could'' be in a World category, in my terms. Also, some more smaller groups, such as the Mushroom Heartless, can be handled with categories if there is mass See Alsos (i.e. it is better than having a link to each other Mushroom on the See Also section).--[[User:Dreyfus2006|Dreyfus]] 01:47, 5 January 2007 (UTC) | ||