KHWiki:Traverse Town: Difference between revisions
→Overategorization
| Line 149: | Line 149: | ||
::See alsos can have relations established by category or comment - the relationship is closer than that of these categories. See also sections also invite improvement, while categories on their own don't - the two are not really comparable. It devalues categories to make them simple correlations - X and Y were involved/intertwined in some Z fashion once in the game, so it gets categorized that way? When I think "Radiant Garden" I think "1000 Heartless, the big mace ball heartless, Merlin, Leon, Sephiroth". I certainly don't think "Xaldin". He did nothing but laugh facelessly. [[User:Scottch|Scottch]] 15:40, 30 December 2006 (UTC) | ::See alsos can have relations established by category or comment - the relationship is closer than that of these categories. See also sections also invite improvement, while categories on their own don't - the two are not really comparable. It devalues categories to make them simple correlations - X and Y were involved/intertwined in some Z fashion once in the game, so it gets categorized that way? When I think "Radiant Garden" I think "1000 Heartless, the big mace ball heartless, Merlin, Leon, Sephiroth". I certainly don't think "Xaldin". He did nothing but laugh facelessly. [[User:Scottch|Scottch]] 15:40, 30 December 2006 (UTC) | ||
:::I strongly agree with Scottch, a character should only be in a world's category if that character only is in that world.--[[User:Painocus|Painocus]] | :::I strongly agree with Scottch, a character should only be in a world's category if that character only is in that world.--[[User:Painocus|Painocus]] | ||
::::That's the format I was using. If it is unique to that world, or is heavily focused on that world (i.e. [[Strafer]] being in the Space Paranoids category as opposed to [[Behemoth]] being in the Olympus Coliseum category). Most Heartless, at least, don't belong in any world category, except maybe the Coliseum-only ones, the bosses, and maybe the Invisibles and Angel Stars (I don't know why; I just feel like they deserve being in End of the World's category). Heartless that have a specific theme, though (i.e. Strafers to Space Paranoids or Defenders to Hollow Bastion) ''could'' be in a World category, in my terms.--[[User:Dreyfus2006|Dreyfus]] 01:47, 5 January 2007 (UTC) | |||