Forum:Worlds' Character Sections

Forums: Index > The World that Never was > Worlds' Character Sections

Eternal Nothingness XIII

Does that mean...it's time for me to go back to where I belong? ^{— 20:48, 25 February 2019 (UTC)}

What is our policy on the characters we include in these? It is incredibly inconsistent across the Wiki; some pages list only residents, while others list every character who visits. I am of the opinion that we only list the former...

TheSilent Hero ^{— 21:19, 25 February 2019 (UTC)}

I think we should list all characters. Listing residents only might be the easier option for Disney worlds, but what about original ones? Do the Organization members at Castle Oblivion count as residents or visitors? And what about in KH3? What is considered their residence there? And it makes sense that when Xaldin is a major character and boss in a Disney world, he is considered one of the characters in that world. On the other hand, it seems unnecessary to put Sora, Donald, and Goofy on almost all world pages.

Eternal Nothingness XIII

So...it seems your hearts have led you to obliteration. Perhaps it doesn't pay to be too loyal to one's heart. I will have to be sure and remember that. ^{— 21:39, 25 February 2019 (UTC)}

If we must list visitors, as well, we must be sure to list them all (including Sora and company), for consistency. Some articles pick and choose which visitors to include, if any. What if we did different tabs for residents and visitors, respectively? That way, it wouldn't look like Xaldin is native to Beast's Castle, and so-on...

KrytenKoro - Click
TALK -

Mightn't we separate these into "natives" and "visitors"/"immigrants"? And maybe we could go for a more compact arrangement, the galleries get pretty big. There's also a bit of a difference between Alice, who is from a different world than Wonderland but is fairly well settled, and Young Xehanort in Toy Box, who is just being a dick.

LightRoxas - "I'm proud to be a small part of something bigger - the people it did choose.
TALK - "I am who I am, because of them."

I would say to start we should focus on residents, and take the perspective of what each individual would consider themselves. So for example, Sora and co. don't think of themselves as part of each world they visit, but Roxas does legitimately think he belongs in Twilight Town in KH2 and thus could be considered a resident. Same with Ansem the Wise and Namine, who live there for nearly a year.

Just my opinion though, that does require less strict guidelines and leaves more up for interpretation then the other options.

TheSilent Hero ^{— 22:50, 25 February 2019 (UTC)}

If we're splitting by residents and visitors, we still have to decide what counts as resident. For example, do Leon and gang count as residents of Traverse Town? They live there for years, but their true home is Radiant Garden. Or what about Mickey in CotM? He says he's not from that world, so that would make him a visitor, but he's from the movie that the world is based on. I think it's better to not split in tabs. The characters section shouldn't be seen as people living in this world, but as people appearing in this world.

For the galleries, we could try making the images smaller.

Eternal Nothingness XIII

Why did the Keyblade choose me? I have to know. ^{— 23:36, 25 February 2019 (UTC)}

Regardless of what we decide, I only ask that it be enforced on all relevant pages, and that we stay consistent across the Wiki. Also, when making the final decision, remember we have two audiences here: people who play the games, and people who do not/are trying to get into them. It may be common knowledge that Xaldin isn't a native of Beast's Castle to us, but newcomers may see the gallery as it currently is and think, "Who is this guy, and why is he living with the Beast?" We've got some thinking to do before we move forward with an official policy, but I'm confident we will reach a verdict soon!

KrytenKoro - "Space Corp Directive 195—In an emergency power situation, a hologrammatic crew member must lay down his life in order that the living crew members might survive."
"Yes, but Rimmer Directive 271 states just as clearly: 'No chance, you metal bastard.'"
TALK -

Also, which images should be used? Agrabah uses the KH3 image for Pete, but uses the KHX images for Mega-Shadow and Powerwild. What's the deal here?

KrytenKoro - "Punch your lights out, hit the pavement. That's what I call entertainment. Causin' problems makes you famous - all the violence makes a statement."
TALK -

Okay, so I'd like to advocate:

Characters section includes two galleries: first for natives (left unnamed), and second for visitors (labeled "Visitors"). Visitors includes both PC characters, and NPCs who are specified as not-native to that world. So, Leon would be visitor in traverse town, Alice would be visitor in Wonderland, and Boo would be visitor in Monstropolis. Not sure how Toy Box would work out. NPCs from a world are assumed to be natives unless explicitly stated otherwise.

Images used are to be from the latest game-release that the character appeared in that world. So, BBS Merlin would be in Radiant Garden, but KH Merlin in Traverse Town.

Concur?

TheSilent Hero ^{— 16:05, 4 March 2019 (UTC)}

I still think we shouldn't split between natives and visitors. It will just be easier to list all characters in the same gallery, rather than decide if they count as native or visitor. Plus, I think one single gallery looks better. I agree about using the images for the game the character appeared in.

KrytenKoro - Most bears were content to live their lives, mauling and eating one, maybe two humans at most. "Mass-murder," as the bears always said, "is for the sharks." But not Barry. Barry was different. He knew that one day, he would kill ALL of the humans. This is the inspiring, tear-jerking story of one bear and the dream he dared to dream.
TALK -

So, you're saying we should include sora, donald, goofy, jiminy, and org members on every world they visit?

TheSilent Hero ^{— 16:23, 4 March 2019 (UTC)} <<<<<<<<<<

Exactly. Although Jiminy is a bit of a gray area, since he isn't seen in every world.

KH1 immigrants

Kairi: Visitor to Destiny Islands, native to Radiant Garden
Jiminy: Visitor to Disney Castle, native to Prankster's Paradise
Alice: Visitor to Wonderland
Simba: Visitor to Traverse Town, native to Pride Lands
Mushu: Visitor to Traverse Town, native to Land of Dragons
Bambi: Visitor to Traverse Town, native to TBD
Dumbo: Visitor to Traverse Town, native to TBD
Dalmations: Visitors to Traverse Town, native to TBD
Leon, Cid, Aerith, Yuffie: Visitors to Traverse Town, native to Radiant Garden
Merlin: calls Traverse Town home?
Beast: Visitor to Hollow Bastion, native to Beast's Castle
Cinderella: Visitor to Hollow Bastion, native to Castle of Dreams
Maleficent, Aurora: Visitors to Hollow Bastion, native to Enchanted Dominion
Snow White: Visitor to Hollow Bastion, native to Dwarf Woodlands