Talk:Mr. Smee

Fourth Wall

Uxie Lover1994 Cuando la vida te da las herramientas, a construir motos libración ^{— 11:26, 28 February 2012 (UTC)}

Smee breaks the fourth wall in the manga. Here's the proof...

Update

Uxie Lover1994 Tiempo de morder de nuevo con el poder! El tema de hoy: su sorpresa! ^{— 12:59, 13 June 2013 (UTC)}

Just checked in the official translation. He does not break the fourth wall at all. Sorry for giving out false detail earlier.

Name

TheSilent Hero ^{— 19:08, 29 December 2014 (UTC)} <<<<<<<<<<

Is his official name "Mr. Smee" or "Smee"? The page is called Mr. Smee, but that name is only used in the BBS Story section.

Eternal Nothingness XIII You're such an idiot. There is no promise, and there never was! You're just delusional. Must you insist on playing the hero? Whatever. If that's the way you want it... You're going down alone! ^{— 20:43, 29 December 2014 (UTC)}

His name should be whatever he is referred to most often across the various games' Journals. That's how I feel our articles should ALWAYS be named...

TheSilent Hero ^{— 22:07, 29 December 2014 (UTC)} <<<<<<<<<<

I believe the Wiki policy is to use the most recent game's name, which is BBS in this case.

TheFifteenthMember Yes. You're creepy. I can't say we'll miss you while you're gone, so it'd be best if you did go. We all win that way. ^{— TheFifteenthMember 00:01, 30 December 2014 (UTC)}

Actually, I believe we are required to use the most stable name that the games provide, which generally is the name that is used most, not particularly the most recent.

KeybladeSpyMaster - I do it for my family, my home, my friends! I do it for her!
TALK -

Welcome to Spy Force One. - 06:13 PM Mon, December 29, 2014 MDT

No, actually, the Manual of Style says we use the first name provided, if the games have changed the subject's name.

"If the official name of a subject has been changed in later episodes of Kingdom Hearts, please use the first name. However, redirects can be made using the later names."

Unless I'm wrong, and the Manual of Style needs to be updated (which, it probably does anyways).

TheFifteenthMember I like white. I find it goes well with yellow, but only if you want it to. ^{— TheFifteenthMember 00:19, 30 December 2014 (UTC)}

Then, I concur. I am satisfied with what you quoted from the MoS.

Eternal Nothingness XIII Organization XIII has no further use for you... Just look there. Our Kingdom Hearts... Thanks to you, we've collected countless hearts... Can you hear their euphoria?

The Manual of Style is severely in need of updating, yes. The policy from the MoS refers to subjects with multiple names, like the Rabid Dog ("Snapper Dog" in 358/2 Days). So Smee does not necessarily fit that. Still, as I said and FifteenthMember said, whichever name is the most "stable" (the one used in the game most often) is the one we should use.