Talk:Destiny's Embrace: Difference between revisions
Line 204: | Line 204: | ||
:: Actually the point is in the interview was that both Riku and Kairi obtained their keyblades in nonstandard ways and its fair to think there is a special meaning to it. The interview even always refers to it as her's not Riku's. Anyway Riku's held it but as for wielding it to battle he has yet to do so I'm not sure its appropriate to list it but if we do it should be labled as Kairi's much like Kingdom Key is labled Sora's and Oblivion is Roxas's. --Lycropath 4:46, 8 May 2012 (UTC) | :: Actually the point is in the interview was that both Riku and Kairi obtained their keyblades in nonstandard ways and its fair to think there is a special meaning to it. The interview even always refers to it as her's not Riku's. Anyway Riku's held it but as for wielding it to battle he has yet to do so I'm not sure its appropriate to list it but if we do it should be labled as Kairi's much like Kingdom Key is labled Sora's and Oblivion is Roxas's. --Lycropath 4:46, 8 May 2012 (UTC) | ||
Something like that, yes. --{{User:Neumannz/SigTemplate}} 12:00, 8 May 2012 (UTC) | Something like that, yes. --{{User:Neumannz/SigTemplate}} 12:00, 8 May 2012 (UTC) | ||
:Honestly, and don't take this harshly, I trust fan-translations as far as I can throw their writers, do to the constant speculation that goes into them. For stuff like this, where a twist of a prounoun can change nearly the entire meaning, it is especially important that we are provided the original Japanese text, rather than just told "hey guys, I translated this". For all we know, he could be talking about "Kairi's Keyblade" in the context of the blade's name, like how he talks about "Terra-Xehanort's Master Xehanort's Keyblade"; and then there's the fact that the original interview translation indicates a carried subject for the "handing it to Kairi", while the new one inserts "Keyblade" there. | |||
:Finally, Riku is the one shown actually summoning it, and the Keyblade pops up again with Aqua NOT being wielded by Kairi, but merely being created by her presence; that and the fact that Riku easily wielded Oblivion despite it belonging to Roxas give strong precedent for it not truly being "the Keyblade belonging to Kairi". That being the case, I've reverted the following two edits, though we can reinstate them if the translation proves to be accurate. | |||
*[http://www.khwiki.net/index.php?title=Destiny%27s_Embrace&action=historysubmit&diff=555375&oldid=549250] | |||
*[http://www.khwiki.net/index.php?title=List_of_Keyblade_wielders&action=historysubmit&diff=555367&oldid=554884] | |||
:All in all, I would feel WAY more comfortable if we were provided the actual text of the interview answer before we go changing everything. You're probably totally, 100% right, but we really need to confirm these things before making changes. | |||
:Neumannz, in case this person doesn't have the text, can you ask Shard for it? I can go a crack at it as soon as I get it, and lay out the translation notes here for you guys' review.[[Special:Contributions/192.249.47.177|192.249.47.177]] 13:49, 8 May 2012 (UTC) |
Revision as of 13:49, 8 May 2012
Keyblade?
Yes, it looks like a keyblade, but was it ever stated that it really is a keyblade?
Well it has a keychain what more proof do you need?--Vatek 23:54, 29 December 2008 (UTC)
yeah... i guess it was a dumb question after all.
|
Stats
Strength and Magic - if this is just a skin change for the Kingdom Key, why would it have different stats?
Does it actually list "No contact" as its ability?
You don't actually get it in that scene, so "get" wouldn't be used.Not even Mr. Lister's Koromon survived intact. 01:17, 13 March 2009 (UTC)
Truth be told, I'm surprised you can even use Codebreaker to use that thing in battle. Like the main article said, it showed up in only one cutscene and is only for show. The fact that you can't use it effectively in battle means that it doesn't have any stats or abilities at all. This may change when Kingdom Hearts III comes out, but for now, the main article put it best: it is only for show. Keyblader 20:41, 26 April 2009 (UTC)
Riku's
Even in Director's Secret Report XIII Nomura never says that the keyblade is Riku's. There is supposedly some deeper meaning in him handing it to her but it's not his.We Still don't know what this thing is only that "it's naturally the same type as Sora's.
|
With that thing? Also he might have been the "Delivery Boy" for it. we still don't know what this thing is.
and it is an assumption that "Kairi was able to use Riku's keyblade".and it should be taken out of the article.and the report may have not related the "Transfer and occurance" with the "Riku's handing it to kairi" statements. in other words while both facts are in the same sentence they may be different, seperate clauses.67.76.40.218 17:27, 24 May 2009 (UTC)
|
(3) in kingdom hearts 1 Riku turns out to be the keyblade's true chosen one and takes it from sora the "Delivery Boy"
and using the translated report for Keyblade V Keyblades is a nice lobsidedness (and the plural rule dosn't seem to apply to that sentence and makes sense either way)
and while the report is accurate the translation may not be. I'd say Japanese is a messed up language but english can be equally difficult. so instead, i'd like to say that translating between them is an inherrently difficult process.so while not discredited,what we have should be taken with a grain of salt. the various KH3.net posts have pictures of the ultimania that can be alternatively translated and should be (and if you think I'm going to after five months of activity and being too lazy too sign up then...)67.76.40.218 03:31, 25 May 2009 (UTC)
|
why does it matter how many keyblades there are?it shows that a keyblade can be used by someone else with the purpose of delivering it to the actual wielder.That's like, three fifths of the issue.
and the issue isn't that the translation is wrong or even "not right". just thaT as the only source, it should be looked into with more care, scrutiny and maybe be analyzed by a japanese reading member of the site, for assissting in interpratation of such issues.
and regardless of plurality riku's keyblade is not conclusively the subject.67.76.40.218 16:32, 26 May 2009 (UTC)
Y'know, i try to be diplomatic, something i'm not very good at (though punching someone in the face across the internet would be much harder) But I can't stand innacuracies or worse yet, lies. the Another Report which I generously provided has been misued, and spread falsehoods the quite simply do not belong. and while that is abused other issues are quite simply ignored.(the kingom hearts Novels, and if you bring up that damn manga i will scream and vandalise every thing on this wiki, just to get the point across.) with Superior Rage,67.76.40.218 04:53, 6 June 2009 (UTC)
|
By "Provided" I meant that I introduced the report to this wiki which had never heard of it before. admitedly I reacted a bit unfavorably in that post. I had a bad day. However when a source is misrepresented while others still are simply ignored that is not something that can be done on such a database. and admitedly when you're wrong that will all be done with and this mistake will be fixed but the timescale is just too large for my tastes67.76.40.218 12:47, 7 June 2009 (UTC)
- ..I don't know what you're talking about, as I had heard of the report on my own before coming to this wiki. And, again, you have provided absolutely no evidence for your claim that the Keyblade is not a Synch Blade of Riku's - you've just been screaming "Lies!" and threatening to vandalize the wiki.
- The report makes it clear that Kairi's Keyblade and the Way to the Dawn are both light-realm Keyblades like Sora's.
- The report strongly suggests that Kairi's Keyblade and Riku's Keyblade are in fact the same thing.
- The report says that it is uncertain how Riku was able to hand a second Keyblade to Kairi; but that it is clear that he had a Keyblade and handed it to her.
i'm almost positive that the kh2 novels provide an alternative explanation,but again they are not represented on this site.i understand that the things are a b**** to find but...
|
|
|
Why shouldn't Riku be able to Dual-Wield? Roxas could do it after he defeated Xion, right? Riku defeated the Riku-Replica in Castle Oblivion, so isn't it possible that Kairi's Gayblade is actually Repliku's Soul Eater? The Keychain is very similar to Namine's good luck charm, which strikes me as a possible reference to Repliku. But even then...is Riku "lending" or "giving" the Gayblade to Kairi? So many questions...
SavageLarxene011 23:03, November 3, 2009 (UTC)
- Because Riku doesn't show constant use of the Synch-Blading, and the Replica Riku is said to be a more imperfect Replica, it is difficult to compare it to the Xion/Roxas situation, in which Roxas clearly became more "complete", and permanently dual-wielded. It's certainly a good theory (there's no real reason why Roxas should be able to gain a Keyblade from Xion but not Riku from Ixion), but it's still hard to say that that's the actual reason. Hopefully we'll get more info in BBS on whether any Keyblader can Synch Blade, or only those who have been copied.Glorious CHAOS! 02:03, November 4, 2009 (UTC)
I do not believe this is a blade of riku's and even so he never really "wielded" this keyblade kairi did which would be better placed as a keyblade of kairi not riku's. also during the time riku handed the keyblade to kairi he was as ansem and completely shrouded in darkness for him to wield a keyblade of light he would then not be completely of "Darkness" as keyblades genearly are linked to the wielder. HighDukeIchi 02:48, November 25, 2010 (UTC)
- Nomura explicitly said that Riku uses a Keyblade of Light, and that the DE is Riku's Keyblade.(ಠ_ೃ) Bully! 06:38, November 25, 2010 (UTC)
the name
|
|
How about "Kairi's Ridiculously Girly Keyblade"? Sums it up nicely, IMHO. JudgmentDay95 19:10 13 July 2009 (UTC)
|
Give Kairi's Keyblade a Name!
Pick a name...make a name...anything you want!but u should make sure that it actually matches...-XionXIV P.S.the name i give it is Garden of Light P.S.S.Oh and the reason i did this was cuz i was bored...heh...
|
yeah i kno...but i was just bored...erase the section if you want...i just like typing... P.S.You rlly brung meh down today.... :(
I settled for "Princess Flower". Charmed-Jay. 2009-sep-14
|
Its a Keychain?
it says here."Kairi's Keyblade is a keychain for Riku's Keyblade which appears in Kingdom Hearts II." I mean the keyblade changes through keychains so how is it that Kairi can wield it if he just gave her a keychain?
- Riku Synched his Keyblade (like with Valor Form), and the form that it took was due to the Keychain on it. It's still Riku's personal Keyblade.Glorious CHAOS! 10:10, October 29, 2009 (UTC)
Similarites to oathkeeper?
Since oathkeeper was formed by soras memories of kairis, what if this is the same thing except its based on Rikus memories of kairi?--Foutlet 17:37, December 1, 2009 (UTC)
Name
|
|
|
|
|
But he just took a break because he's been playing for 15 hours.Glorious CHAOS! 00:02, January 9, 2010 (UTC)
{
|
Picture
|
|
... Noticeably different? They look completely identical:
72.77.96.235 06:18, February 2, 2010 (UTC)
|
Since Aqua had this keyblade...
How exactly did Riku obtain and give it to Kairi? Nomura even said that the scene where he does hints at something. Vaddie 12:31, January 29, 2010 (UTC)
- Likely, it is simply that the Keyblade is connected to Kairi. Riku summoned it for Kairi's use, and Aqua obtained it after meeting with her. (I guess this would make it the non-Sora version of the Oathkeeper?) What it fully means, and if it fully means anything, we do not yet know.--Otherarrow 12:38, January 29, 2010 (UTC)
|
Well the last time we see aqua's old keyblade is when Xemnas went to "sleep" in Radiant Garden during the battle there. Riku first shows his keyblade at twtnw. what if, as he's helping sora behind the scenes, he finds the Chamber of Repose and gets aqua's keyblade to give it to kairi70.144.122.234 20:08, February 5, 2010 (UTC)
It is possible since if you use codes to go there rhe armor isn't there--Xabryn 11:21, February 6, 2010 (UTC)
- At the same time, there's no reason for it to be there. Hacking COM to let Riku go to Moogle shops will show Sora there because Riku would never go there, surely.—Urutapu 20:37, February 6, 2010 (UTC)
Destiny's Embrace's Origins
Just a quick question. Does Destiny's Embrace really resemble Destiny Islands?
I just read in the keyblade's design that "The Keyblade is round and curvaceous to the point of appearing non-dangerous. One side of the hilt is formed in the shape of a breaking ocean wave, while the other is formed into a beige vine of sand which wraps around the sunset shaft to burst forth into a bouquet of flowers for the teeth in resemblance to their home world, Destiny Islands"
If my memory serves me right, I don't remember there being any flowers in Destiny Islands. I think Destiny's Embrace is actually a keyblade from Radiant Garden. I mean, Kairi's home world is Radiant Garden, and Aqua acquired that keyblade from Kairi in Radiant Garden, plus the fact the Kairi hasn't even been to Destiny Islands during that event.
I can understand that most people thought that this keyblade represented Destiny Islands because of the Paopu fruit token, but to me, it feels like it leans more to Radiant Garden than Destiny Islands.
What do you guys think?
|
How do I do that?
Sorry I'm a noob around here. :P
|
huh?
|
Like Xabryn said it seems to represent both places so shouldn't that be mentioned? I mean like the hilt/guard is reminiscent of the waves and beach of the Destiny Islands whereas the teeth seem to represent the flowers and beauty of the Radiant Garden and i guess one could say that the middle is for her transition from one wold to another. So just to reiterate should both worlds be mentioned in the design section?--Chaosxterra09 15:04, September 3, 2010 (UTC)Chaosxterra09
Finally, a name...
I've longed to know what the real name of this Keyblade is, but didn't dare to speculate much. Finally, now I know its name. It sure is a relief.--Charmed-Jay 09:36, November 10, 2010 (UTC)
Not Riku's
Well sorry to bring this old horse up again but I think its obvious with how the plot is progressing now that when he talks about Soul Eater transforming it is about Way to the Dawn, not Destiny's Embrace Whats wrong here is the translation makes it sound like he is talking about the same thing but he is not, Kairi's keyblade is hers and hers alone, not Riku's another translation here http://www.kh-info-block.tumblr.com/tagged/KHIINom has it as "Handing a keyblade to Kairi" so I think its safe to say that this whole Riku's keyblade has been an issue blown out of proportion through a minor translation issue amusingly enough.
- Sign your posts.
- It wouldn't be the first time a mistranslation caused problems... Anyway, I always thought it was something like this.
- On the other hand, just because that keyblade is separate from WttD doesn't mean Riku wasn't wielding it. After all, Mickey can summon two different keyblades, one from the realm of light and one from the realm of darkness. We still don't know where he got it from, although I think I can guess... --Neumannz, The Dark Falcon 10:54, 8 May 2012 (UTC)
- Actually the point is in the interview was that both Riku and Kairi obtained their keyblades in nonstandard ways and its fair to think there is a special meaning to it. The interview even always refers to it as her's not Riku's. Anyway Riku's held it but as for wielding it to battle he has yet to do so I'm not sure its appropriate to list it but if we do it should be labled as Kairi's much like Kingdom Key is labled Sora's and Oblivion is Roxas's. --Lycropath 4:46, 8 May 2012 (UTC)
Something like that, yes. --Neumannz, The Dark Falcon 12:00, 8 May 2012 (UTC)
- Honestly, and don't take this harshly, I trust fan-translations as far as I can throw their writers, do to the constant speculation that goes into them. For stuff like this, where a twist of a prounoun can change nearly the entire meaning, it is especially important that we are provided the original Japanese text, rather than just told "hey guys, I translated this". For all we know, he could be talking about "Kairi's Keyblade" in the context of the blade's name, like how he talks about "Terra-Xehanort's Master Xehanort's Keyblade"; and then there's the fact that the original interview translation indicates a carried subject for the "handing it to Kairi", while the new one inserts "Keyblade" there.
- Finally, Riku is the one shown actually summoning it, and the Keyblade pops up again with Aqua NOT being wielded by Kairi, but merely being created by her presence; that and the fact that Riku easily wielded Oblivion despite it belonging to Roxas give strong precedent for it not truly being "the Keyblade belonging to Kairi". That being the case, I've reverted the following two edits, though we can reinstate them if the translation proves to be accurate.
- All in all, I would feel WAY more comfortable if we were provided the actual text of the interview answer before we go changing everything. You're probably totally, 100% right, but we really need to confirm these things before making changes.
- Neumannz, in case this person doesn't have the text, can you ask Shard for it? I can go a crack at it as soon as I get it, and lay out the translation notes here for you guys' review.192.249.47.177 13:49, 8 May 2012 (UTC)