Forum:Redirected abilities: Difference between revisions
No edit summary |
Chitalian8 (talk | contribs) (That's all of them.) |
||
| (24 intermediate revisions by 4 users not shown) | |||
| Line 7: | Line 7: | ||
{{col-start}} | {{col-start}} | ||
{{col-break}} | {{col-break}} | ||
*{{RD|Aerial Dive}} | *<s>{{RD|Aerial Dive}}</s> | ||
*{{RD|Aerial Finish}} | *<s>{{RD|Aerial Finish}}</s> | ||
*<s>{{RD|Anti Glide}}</s> | *<s>{{RD|Anti Glide}}</s> | ||
*<s>{{RD|Aero Potion}}</s> | *<s>{{RD|Aero Potion}}</s> | ||
*{{RD|Applause!}} | *<s>{{RD|Applause!}}</s> | ||
*<s>{{RD|Applause, Applause}}</s> | *<s>{{RD|Applause, Applause}}</s> | ||
*{{RD|Auto Assault}} | *<s>{{RD|Auto Assault}}</s> | ||
*{{RD|Auto Final}} | *<s>{{RD|Auto Final}}</s> | ||
*{{RD|Auto Limit}} | *<s>{{RD|Auto Limit}}</s> | ||
*{{RD|Auto Master}} | *<s>{{RD|Auto Master}}</s> | ||
*{{RD|Auto Summon}} | *<s>{{RD|Auto Summon}}</s> | ||
*{{RD|Auto Valor}} | *<s>{{RD|Auto Valor}}</s> | ||
*{{RD|Auto Wisdom}} | *<s>{{RD|Auto Wisdom}}</s> | ||
*{{RD|Blazing Fury}} | *<s>{{RD|Blazing Fury}}</s> | ||
*<s>{{RD|Bolts of Sorrow}}</s> | *<s>{{RD|Bolts of Sorrow}}</s> | ||
*{{RD|Bone Smash}} | *<s>{{RD|Bone Smash}}</s> | ||
*{{RD|Brave Beat}} | *<s>{{RD|Brave Beat}}</s> | ||
*{{RD|Brave Shot}} | *<s>{{RD|Brave Shot}}</s> | ||
*<s>{{RD|Comet}}</s> | *<s>{{RD|Comet}}</s> | ||
*{{RD|Complete Compilement}} | *<s><{{RD|Complete Compilement}}</s> | ||
*{{RD|Crime & Punishment}} | *<s>{{RD|Crime & Punishment}}</s> | ||
*{{RD|Dark Shield}} | *<s>{{RD|Dark Shield}}</s> | ||
*{{RD|Disaster}} | *<s>{{RD|Disaster}}</s> | ||
*{{RD|Divider}} | *<s>{{RD|Divider}}</s> | ||
*{{RD|Dodge Slash}} | *<s>{{RD|Dodge Slash}}</s> | ||
*<s>{{RD|Donald Blizzard}}</s> | |||
{{col-break}} | {{col-break}} | ||
*<s>{{RD|Donald Cure}}</s> | *<s>{{RD|Donald Cure}}</s> | ||
*<s>{{RD|Donald Fire}}</s> | *<s>{{RD|Donald Fire}}</s> | ||
*<s>{{RD|Donald Thunder}}</s> | *<s>{{RD|Donald Thunder}}</s> | ||
*{{RD|Dragonblaze}} | *<s>{{RD|Dragonblaze}}</s> | ||
*{{RD|Eternal Session}} | *<s>{{RD|Eternal Session}}</s> | ||
*<s>{{RD|Fantasia}}</s> | *<s>{{RD|Fantasia}}</s> | ||
*{{RD|Ferocious Lunge}} | *<s>{{RD|Ferocious Lunge}}</s> | ||
*{{RD|Ferocious Rush}} | *<s>{{RD|Ferocious Rush}}</s> | ||
*{{RD|Fierce Claw}} | *<s>{{RD|Fierce Claw}}</s> | ||
*{{RD|Final Arcana}} | *<s>{{RD|Final Arcana}}</s> | ||
*{{RD|Final Arts}} | *<s>{{RD|Final Arts}}</s> | ||
*{{RD|Final Strike}} | *<s>{{RD|Final Strike}}</s> | ||
*{{RD|Flametongue}} | *<s>{{RD|Flametongue}}</s> | ||
*{{RD|Flare Force}} | *<s>{{RD|Flare Force}}</s> | ||
*{{RD|Flash Step}} | *<s>{{RD|Flash Step}}</s> | ||
*{{RD|Furious Shout}} | *<s>{{RD|Furious Shout}}</s> | ||
*{{RD|Ghostly Scream}} | *<s>{{RD|Ghostly Scream}}</s> | ||
*<s>[[Groundshaker (ability)]]</s> | |||
*<s>{{RD|Goofy Bash}}</s> | *<s>{{RD|Goofy Bash}}</s> | ||
*{{RD|Guard Break}} | *<s>{{RD|Guard Break}}</s> | ||
*{{RD|Healing Water}} | *<s>{{RD|Healing Water}}</s> | ||
*{{RD|Horizontal Slash}} | *<s>{{RD|Horizontal Slash}}</s> | ||
*{{RD|Howling Moon}} | *<s>{{RD|Howling Moon}}</s> | ||
*{{RD|Icy Terror}} | *<s>{{RD|Icy Terror}}</s> | ||
*{{RD| | *<s>{{RD|King's Pride}}</s> | ||
*<s>{{RD|Light & Dark}}</s> | |||
{{col-break}} | {{col-break}} | ||
*{{RD| | *<s>{{RD|Magic Spice}}</s> | ||
*{{RD| | *<s>{{RD|Magnet Burst}}</s> | ||
*{{RD|Magnet Splash}} | *<s>{{RD|Magnet Splash}}</s> | ||
*{{RD|Master Magic}} | *<s>{{RD|Master Magic}}</s> | ||
*{{RD|Master Strike}} | *<s>{{RD|Master Strike}}</s> | ||
*{{RD|Mushu Fire}} | *<s>{{RD|Mushu Fire}}</s> | ||
*{{RD|No Mercy}} | *<s>{{RD|No Mercy}}</s> | ||
*{{RD|Omega Finale}} | *<s>{{RD|Omega Finale}}</s> | ||
*{{RD|Over the Horizon}} | *<s>{{RD|Over the Horizon}}</s> | ||
*{{RD|Pulsing Thunder}} | *<s>[[Overdrive (Limit)]]</s> | ||
*{{RD|Quickplay}} | *<s>{{RD|Pulsing Thunder}}</s> | ||
*{{RD|Reflect Combo}} | *<s>{{RD|Quickplay}}</s> | ||
*{{RD|Round Break}} | *<s>{{RD|Rain Storm}}</s> | ||
*{{RD|Scouting Disk}} | *<s>{{RD|Reflect Combo}}</s> | ||
*{{RD|Slash Frenzy}} | *<s>{{RD|Round Break}}</s> | ||
*{{RD|Sonic End}} | *<s>{{RD|Scouting Disk}}</s> | ||
*{{RD|Sonic Strike}} | *<s>{{RD|Slash Frenzy}}</s> | ||
*<s>{{RD|Sonic End}}</s> | |||
*<s>{{RD|Sonic Strike}}</s> | |||
*<s>{{RD|Teamwork}}</s> | *<s>{{RD|Teamwork}}</s> | ||
*<s>{{RD|Tornado Fusion}}</s> | *<s>{{RD|Tornado Fusion}}</s> | ||
*{{RD|Treasure Isle}} | *<s>{{RD|Treasure Isle}}</s> | ||
*{{RD|Trick Fantasy}} | *<s>{{RD|Trick Fantasy}}</s> | ||
*{{RD|Upper Slash}} | *<s>{{RD|Upper Slash}}</s> | ||
*<s>{{RD|Vicinity Break}}</s> | |||
*<s>{{RD|Wind Armor}}</s> | *<s>{{RD|Wind Armor}}</s> | ||
*{{RD|Wisdom Shot}} | *<s>{{RD|Wisdom Shot}}</s> | ||
{{col-end}} | {{col-end}} | ||
</div> | </div> | ||
| Line 117: | Line 122: | ||
@Amaury: It says there is an ability in the article...why is it described but not listed in the bullet points below? {{User:ANX219/Sig}} 01:22, 23 October 2014 (UTC) | @Amaury: It says there is an ability in the article...why is it described but not listed in the bullet points below? {{User:ANX219/Sig}} 01:22, 23 October 2014 (UTC) | ||
:Ghostly Terror isn't an ability. Ghostly Scream is, however. - [[User:Amaury|Amaury]] ([[User talk:Amaury|talk]]) 01:34, 23 October 2014 (UTC) | :Ghostly Terror isn't an ability. Ghostly Scream is, however. - [[User:Amaury|Amaury]] ([[User talk:Amaury|talk]]) 01:34, 23 October 2014 (UTC) | ||
::Agree with KSM and Neumannz. The main ability is the "holder" for all of the following commands, which should simply be redirects. ''However'', in the special case of subcommands which are similar to full commands (as with Dark Cannon as part of Session and as its own attack in BBS), the full command should have additional coverage of the subcommand version as "other appearances" (which I believe is what is currently done on that page). | |||
::Not sure how to deal with RC-chains, though, which are invoked outside of Limits. For example Bump > Meteor Spike. Thoughts?{{User:KrytenKoro/Sig}} 21:13, 12 January 2015 (UTC) | |||
Reaction Commands are a huge can of worms we have to deal with still, probably beyond the scope of this particular thread. In the end the most sensible coverage we might be able to do is a charted list, except for those like Reversal which have other appearances. --{{User:Neumannz/SigTemplate}} 02:35, 13 January 2015 (UTC) | |||
==Limit similarities== | |||
Should we note clear similarities between limits and other attacks in an "Other appearances" section? For example, Axel's sleight Firetooth is essentially the same attack as his limit, Explosion. {{User:TheFifteenthMember/Sig1}} 12:03, 5 April 2015 (UTC) | |||
:Yes, but they need to be strong similarities.{{User:KrytenKoro/Sig}} 03:12, 6 April 2015 (UTC) | |||
Another question on limits (this time KH2): what should we write for their leads? Currently, they just rehash the game description saying "Together, X and Y can use the Z attack." But that's sloppy to be completely honest. Any alternatives? {{User:TheFifteenthMember/Sig1}} 20:36, 18 May 2015 (UTC) | |||
Latest revision as of 13:44, 2 September 2015
|
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
They should all be on the main Abilities pages, but if we're missing any you can try to look them us elsewhere. --Neumannz, The Dark Falcon 01:42, 28 August 2014 (UTC)
- Okay. I was checking on the ability sections on the character articles before. TheFifteenthMember 23:33, 28 August 2014 (UTC)
What's the format for limits? As I understand it, each limit has an ability that enables it and several sequenced commands during activation. For example, the Dance Call limit is enabled through the Applause, Applause ability and the limit starts with the "Dancebeat" command and then continues into the "Finale" command. Should the ability and the limit (and its various commands) be covered on the same page or on separate pages? TheFifteenthMember 14:06, 26 September 2014 (UTC)
- I think the ability should have a page separate from the actual limit and its various attacks. Thoughts? TheFifteenthMember 10:02, 28 September 2014 (UTC)
Wouldn't that make the pages really short? RikutheBloody 10:34, 28 September 2014 (UTC)
I would put the ability and limit on the same page, as they are part of the same attack. TheSilentHero 11:11, 28 September 2014 (UTC)
- Length isn't an issue; our ability abilities are proof that a page doesn't need to be long to be effective. Technically, the ability isn't part of the attack. The ability simply enables the attack to be triggered. Hence, I consider them to be separate enough to deserve the own pages. Besides, if they were joined, would the article name be the ability or the attack? TheFifteenthMember 12:27, 28 September 2014 (UTC)
- It's tough, because the ability and the limit are inexorably linked. Do we have a similar situation where we combined as one or split into two? --Neumannz, The Dark Falcon 17:47, 28 September 2014 (UTC)
I'd think those definitely need to be split. Those articles are outdated so they haven't caught up to the "every ability gets its own page" rule. That's necessary for cases like Donald and Goofy, where their finish commands appear in other games too. —Preceding unsigned comment added by TheFifteenthMember (talk • contribs)
- But I think they shouldn't be split. Like for "Strike Raid", we didn't split "Raid" and "Judgment". We didn't split Command Styles from their finishers as well.
- EDIT: Also, splitting will make the GIFs harder to capture since they only last a few seconds. Pea14733 ---- [雷] 17:32, 1 October 2014 (UTC)
We could use the Youmay template. RikutheBloody 17:35, 1 October 2014 (UTC)
The article should be under the name that appears in the journal for the limit—which, in a case of SHEER COINCIDENCE (O.O)—is the name of the ability. E.g., Fantasia is the name of one of Donald's limits, and its consists of the Comet and Comet Rain attacks. --Neumannz, The Dark Falcon 05:16, 6 October 2014 (UTC)
- If that's the name of the limit and the ability, then I say let's do it there, and redirect the attack names (Like Comet) to those pages.
KeybladeSpyMaster 16:40, 6 October 2014 (UTC)
@Amaury: It says there is an ability in the article...why is it described but not listed in the bullet points below? 
ANX219 01:22, 23 October 2014 (UTC)
- Ghostly Terror isn't an ability. Ghostly Scream is, however. - Amaury (talk) 01:34, 23 October 2014 (UTC)
- Agree with KSM and Neumannz. The main ability is the "holder" for all of the following commands, which should simply be redirects. However, in the special case of subcommands which are similar to full commands (as with Dark Cannon as part of Session and as its own attack in BBS), the full command should have additional coverage of the subcommand version as "other appearances" (which I believe is what is currently done on that page).
- Not sure how to deal with RC-chains, though, which are invoked outside of Limits. For example Bump > Meteor Spike. Thoughts?"We're werewolves, not swearwolves." (KrytenKoro) 21:13, 12 January 2015 (UTC)
Reaction Commands are a huge can of worms we have to deal with still, probably beyond the scope of this particular thread. In the end the most sensible coverage we might be able to do is a charted list, except for those like Reversal which have other appearances. --Neumannz, The Dark Falcon 02:35, 13 January 2015 (UTC)
Limit similarities[edit]
Should we note clear similarities between limits and other attacks in an "Other appearances" section? For example, Axel's sleight Firetooth is essentially the same attack as his limit, Explosion. TheFifteenthMember 12:03, 5 April 2015 (UTC)
- Yes, but they need to be strong similarities."We're werewolves, not swearwolves." (KrytenKoro) 03:12, 6 April 2015 (UTC)
Another question on limits (this time KH2): what should we write for their leads? Currently, they just rehash the game description saying "Together, X and Y can use the Z attack." But that's sloppy to be completely honest. Any alternatives? TheFifteenthMember 20:36, 18 May 2015 (UTC)
