KHWiki:Pages for deletion/Archives/2009 JanMar: Difference between revisions
(Archivin' the rest of March...) |
m (Text replacement - "== ([^=])" to "== $1") |
||
(15 intermediate revisions by 5 users not shown) | |||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
This is an archive page for deletion discussions on the | This is an archive page for deletion discussions on the Kingdom Hearts Wiki for January, February, and March 2009. These discussions are considered ''closed''. Please bring up any further issues on the current deletions page. | ||
== Disorganizationxiii == | == Disorganizationxiii == | ||
I think Disorganizationxiii needs to be Deletion. its fan stuff. so I'll leave you guys to remove it[[User:Eliskuya2|Eliskuya2]] 17:37, 25 January 2009 (UTC) | I think Disorganizationxiii needs to be Deletion. its fan stuff. so I'll leave you guys to remove it[[User:Eliskuya2|Eliskuya2]] 17:37, 25 January 2009 (UTC) | ||
I object. It's really the best out of all parodies out there and clearly deserves | I object. It's really the best out of all parodies out there and clearly deserves its own wiki. It's not really fan stuff. If it were fan stuff, it would just be somebody saying, "I LOVE ORGANIZATION XIII!" or just put random pics and facts about kingdom hearts on the page. It's an official series that should be kept here. Please. I worked forever on that page. | ||
:We don't do fan works here, unless it's on a user page. And even then, we're not big fans of shameless self-promotion. '''Deleted'''. [[User:BebopKate|BebopKate]] 02:15, 26 January 2009 (UTC) | :We don't do fan works here, unless it's on a user page. And even then, we're not big fans of shameless self-promotion. '''Deleted'''. [[User:BebopKate|BebopKate]] 02:15, 26 January 2009 (UTC) | ||
Line 13: | Line 12: | ||
{{TNE|shocktext=Did someone just roll back the changes to Disorganization XIII ? o.O It's the same as I last saw it.}} | {{TNE|shocktext=Did someone just roll back the changes to Disorganization XIII ? o.O It's the same as I last saw it.}} | ||
they need to make a wiki for all fan things | they need to make a wiki for all fan things etc. and I hope this time it gets deletion[[User:Eliskuya2|Eliskuya2]] 04:47, 26 January 2009 (UTC) | ||
{{TNE|text=yeah. I mean, KHWiki is meant for official KH stuff. For a moment there I '''was''' all fascinated with the idea of Disorganization XIII, but na, it shouldn't take its place here.}} | {{TNE|text=yeah. I mean, KHWiki is meant for official KH stuff. For a moment there I '''was''' all fascinated with the idea of Disorganization XIII, but na, it shouldn't take its place here.}} | ||
Line 21: | Line 20: | ||
XienZo got it the other two times. Protected now, and if it somehow reappears, the poster is ''banned''. [[User:BebopKate|BebopKate]] 02:23, 27 January 2009 (UTC) | XienZo got it the other two times. Protected now, and if it somehow reappears, the poster is ''banned''. [[User:BebopKate|BebopKate]] 02:23, 27 January 2009 (UTC) | ||
if I see | if I see an other I well late you guys duel with it peace[[User:Eliskuya2|Eliskuya2]] 02:51, 27 January 2009 (UTC) | ||
{{TNE|text=Eliskuya2: Sure thing. :) I'm counting on you for that one. | {{TNE|text=Eliskuya2: Sure thing. :) I'm counting on you for that one. | ||
Line 41: | Line 40: | ||
BebopKate: I'm beginning to wonder if that's all the author of DXIII does with his life. Honestly. I mean, how does '''he''' gain access to that many computers ?}} | BebopKate: I'm beginning to wonder if that's all the author of DXIII does with his life. Honestly. I mean, how does '''he''' gain access to that many computers ?}} | ||
I think if I see | I think if I see an other again block the user and the site to the "Disorganizationxiii" thing as well and good night brother Bebop and sister Troisnyxe[[User:Eliskuya2|Eliskuya2]] 11:25, 1 February 2009 (UTC) | ||
{{TNE|text=Sure. Oyasumi nasai ! | {{TNE|text=Sure. Oyasumi nasai ! | ||
Line 53: | Line 52: | ||
{{TNE|text=Far as I know, I never downvoted Disorganization XIII before... I'm yet to watch them, actually. But darn it man. Now we are plagued by this jerk who keeps changing computers like anything ! | {{TNE|text=Far as I know, I never downvoted Disorganization XIII before... I'm yet to watch them, actually. But darn it man. Now we are plagued by this jerk who keeps changing computers like anything ! | ||
ugh, and I realised that this is the longest discussion in | ugh, and I realised that this is the longest discussion in pages for deletion.}} | ||
==There's a page called TroisNyxEtienneText, under templates== | ==There's a page called TroisNyxEtienneText, under templates== | ||
Line 65: | Line 64: | ||
==Arch Behemoth and Destroyed Behemoth== | ==Arch Behemoth and Destroyed Behemoth== | ||
{{TNE|text=The two articles are stubs, and the two enemies are palette swaps of the original [[Behemoth]]. Methinks they should be removed and fused with the original Behemoth, and their appearances should be listed there as well. Just like we did for Rune Master and all those other palette-swap Final Mix enemies. What do you think ?}} | {{TNE|text=The two articles are stubs, and the two enemies are palette swaps of the original [[Behemoth]]. Methinks they should be removed and fused with the original Behemoth, and their appearances should be listed there as well. Just like we did for Rune Master and all those other palette-swap Final Mix enemies. What do you think ?}} | ||
Line 88: | Line 86: | ||
{{TNE|text=If there's an evident difference in fighting style between two similar-looking enemies, then they should have their separate pages. Palette swaps should be combined. Or at least, I'm upholding that view. The same goes for [[Trick Ghost]] and [[Magic Ghost]], their pages can be combined into one.}} | {{TNE|text=If there's an evident difference in fighting style between two similar-looking enemies, then they should have their separate pages. Palette swaps should be combined. Or at least, I'm upholding that view. The same goes for [[Trick Ghost]] and [[Magic Ghost]], their pages can be combined into one.}} | ||
::As of now, the Behemoth article does not mention Arc or Destroyed Behemoth's at all, and in fact incorrectly reports that regular Behemoth's were seen in the 1000 Heartless battle. Before any deletions occur, how about the sections be merged first? | ::As of now, the Behemoth article does not mention Arc or Destroyed Behemoth's at all, and in fact incorrectly reports that regular Behemoth's were seen in the 1000 Heartless battle. Before any deletions occur, how about the sections be merged first? | ||
::A the Digimon Wiki, we've had a similar problem, and we've dealt with it with a middle ground between the two positions advocated here. As seen in articles like [http://digimon.wikia.com/wiki/Agumon this one], each version of a "type" of enemy is given a section in the page - kind of like a list article. This method could also be applied to Red Nocturne types, so that there's not too much hair-splitting and argumentation - all of that "type" of enemy is in one article, but each gets its own section. So, Soldiers and Stealth Soldiers would be on one page, all five types of mushrooms, etc. The only problem then is figuring out a name for the entire article - I would suggest | ::A the Digimon Wiki, we've had a similar problem, and we've dealt with it with a middle ground between the two positions advocated here. As seen in articles like [http://digimon.wikia.com/wiki/Agumon this one], each version of a "type" of enemy is given a section in the page - kind of like a list article. This method could also be applied to Red Nocturne types, so that there's not too much hair-splitting and argumentation - all of that "type" of enemy is in one article, but each gets its own section. So, Soldiers and Stealth Soldiers would be on one page, all five types of mushrooms, etc. The only problem then is figuring out a name for the entire article - I would suggest Behemoth Heartless, Wizard Heartless (as the rhapsodies/nocturnes are all said to be a subset of Wizard class), Soldier Heartless, Mushroom Heartless, etc. (or some version of that naming scheme). This way, you could | ||
#Get rid of short, stubby articles, by changing them into short sections of a larger page | #Get rid of short, stubby articles, by changing them into short sections of a larger page | ||
#Allow readers to directly and easily compare variations of a central theme | #Allow readers to directly and easily compare variations of a central theme | ||
Line 103: | Line 101: | ||
{{TNE|text=Methinks it'd depend on the fighting style.}} | {{TNE|text=Methinks it'd depend on the fighting style.}} | ||
== | ==Cerberus (Enemy)== | ||
{{Guardian Soul|text=Cerberus never actually communicates with Sora verbally, so his main page can also be considered his enemy page. We don't really need an enemy version if we can include everything on the main article.}} | {{Guardian Soul|text=Cerberus never actually communicates with Sora verbally, so his main page can also be considered his enemy page. We don't really need an enemy version if we can include everything on the main article.}} | ||
Line 120: | Line 118: | ||
{{Guardian Soul|text=:]}} | {{Guardian Soul|text=:]}} | ||
== | == Narnia == | ||
{{MM841|Sanctuary|Because there is no such world in kh as narnia. }} | {{MM841|Sanctuary|Because there is no such world in kh as narnia. }} | ||
== | == ED Pills == | ||
{{MM841|sweet transvestite|Because its not KH.}} | {{MM841|sweet transvestite|Because its not KH.}} | ||
== | == Template:Radiant Garden == | ||
{{PaintedDragonTalk|time=1:28 pm, 4 March 2009|text=I noticed it was nominated for deletion, I totally agree with that. I was trying to create a new userbox and titled it wrong, so the article is worthless. Sorry guys!}} | {{PaintedDragonTalk|time=1:28 pm, 4 March 2009|text=I noticed it was nominated for deletion, I totally agree with that. I was trying to create a new userbox and titled it wrong, so the article is worthless. Sorry guys!}} | ||
== Images == | == Images == | ||
All of the images listed for deletion are superseded files that have been replaced with cleaner images and standardized names. Please delete them.[[User:KrytenKoro|<small>Not even Mr. Lister's Koromon</small>]] [[User_talk:KrytenKoro|<small>survived intact.</small>]] 23:36, 5 March 2009 (UTC) | All of the images listed for deletion are superseded files that have been replaced with cleaner images and standardized names. Please delete them.[[User:KrytenKoro|<small>Not even Mr. Lister's Koromon</small>]] [[User_talk:KrytenKoro|<small>survived intact.</small>]] 23:36, 5 March 2009 (UTC) | ||
== | ==Detection Saber== | ||
{{TNE|text=Firstly, it was removed from the game. Secondly, it's a palette swap of Ultima Weapon. And thirdly, there isn't any picture for it in the menu - the only thing we can see is a map icon ! | {{TNE|text=Firstly, it was removed from the game. Secondly, it's a palette swap of Ultima Weapon. And thirdly, there isn't any picture for it in the menu - the only thing we can see is a map icon ! | ||
Line 144: | Line 139: | ||
==The language-0 templates== | ==The language-0 templates== | ||
{{TNE|text=I had a talk with Xiggie and Xahno yesterday and we were thinking : since this is an English wiki, then the only language-0 template we need is '''en-0''' (that too, after someone helps us to deal with it !). If we don't speak '''(insert random language here)''' then we don't indicate anything, do we ? | {{TNE|text=I had a talk with Xiggie and Xahno yesterday and we were thinking : since this is an English wiki, then the only language-0 template we need is '''en-0''' (that too, after someone helps us to deal with it !). If we don't speak '''(insert random language here)''' then we don't indicate anything, do we ? | ||
Line 152: | Line 146: | ||
==[[Arch Wyvern]]== | ==[[Arch Wyvern]]== | ||
{{TNE|text=It's one of the stubbiest articles ever. And plus, it's the only variant of Wyvern in Kingdom Hearts: Final Mix. So both the Wyvern and the Arch Wyvern have the same moveset, bu the Arch Wyvern is a palette swap of the former. | {{TNE|text=It's one of the stubbiest articles ever. And plus, it's the only variant of Wyvern in Kingdom Hearts: Final Mix. So both the Wyvern and the Arch Wyvern have the same moveset, bu the Arch Wyvern is a palette swap of the former. | ||
Line 167: | Line 160: | ||
{{BebopKate|text=Thank you. ^_^ '''Deleted'''.}} | {{BebopKate|text=Thank you. ^_^ '''Deleted'''.}} | ||
== | == Heart of destany == | ||
{{MM841||Just a picture and nothing else, and even if it had anything to do with KH, Destany is spelt wrongly.}} | {{MM841||Just a picture and nothing else, and even if it had anything to do with KH, Destany is spelt wrongly.}} | ||
Sigh...not him again. '''Deleted''' [[User:BebopKate|BebopKate]] 22:55, 22 March 2009 (UTC) | Sigh...not him again. '''Deleted''' [[User:BebopKate|BebopKate]] 22:55, 22 March 2009 (UTC) | ||
== | ==Plane Crazy== | ||
{{TNE|text=An unknown IP created this. Worse still, it hasn't got any content in it. Please do take it off. Thanks. ^_^}} | {{TNE|text=An unknown IP created this. Worse still, it hasn't got any content in it. Please do take it off. Thanks. ^_^}} | ||
Line 181: | Line 174: | ||
{{KrytenKoro|I fixed the link so that your text shows, and so that it doesn't show up in that category.}} | {{KrytenKoro|I fixed the link so that your text shows, and so that it doesn't show up in that category.}} | ||
== | ==Sora & Kairi's kiss ?== | ||
{{TNE|shocktext=We are all skeptical over the originality of that image. Also, nothing official's been said by Nomura about this. The way the article's written (it's stubby too !) - it kinda tells me some SoraxKairi-crazed anonymous would've done this. Think we should have it removed ?}} | {{TNE|shocktext=We are all skeptical over the originality of that image. Also, nothing official's been said by Nomura about this. The way the article's written (it's stubby too !) - it kinda tells me some SoraxKairi-crazed anonymous would've done this. Think we should have it removed ?}} | ||
{{Guardian Soul|text=Yeah, the image is an obvious shop.}} | {{Guardian Soul|text=Yeah, the image is an obvious shop.}} | ||
Line 200: | Line 192: | ||
{{TNE|text=Oh. Okay. (I mean, this one was poorly written that I couldn't make out whether it was a locked-away drive form or just a palette swap of all the drives in the disc.)}} | {{TNE|text=Oh. Okay. (I mean, this one was poorly written that I couldn't make out whether it was a locked-away drive form or just a palette swap of all the drives in the disc.)}} | ||
== | ==Xevents== | ||
{{TNE|shocktext=Dang, we've been having too many people filling the | {{TNE|shocktext=Dang, we've been having too many people filling the wiki with unnecessary pages of late.}} | ||
{{BebopKate|text='''Deleted'''. Meh, it's all part of the fun. ^_-}} | {{BebopKate|text='''Deleted'''. Meh, it's all part of the fun. ^_-}} | ||
== | == Caterpillar == | ||
I don't think that characters or places from V Cast should have their own articles, seeing as V Cast isn't canon to the series and is more like a side thing, such as manga or the KH card game. Everything from V Cast should be kept in that one article. [[User:Guardian Soul|Guardian Soul]] 07:21, 14 January 2009 (UTC) | I don't think that characters or places from V Cast should have their own articles, seeing as V Cast isn't canon to the series and is more like a side thing, such as manga or the KH card game. Everything from V Cast should be kept in that one article. [[User:Guardian Soul|Guardian Soul]] 07:21, 14 January 2009 (UTC) | ||
Line 218: | Line 209: | ||
{{TalkTextTest2 | {{TalkTextTest2 | ||
|image= | |image=Marluxia (Talk sprite) 3 KHCOM.png|95px]] | ||
|color=hotpink | |color=hotpink | ||
|color2=black | |color2=black | ||
Line 230: | Line 221: | ||
|text= While Kingdom Hearts V Cast is not part of the main series of Kingdom Hearts, it is put under the Kingdom Hearts Wiki due to its title. While [[Kingdom Hearts V CAST]] remains a part of this Wiki, any characters, worlds, and the plot should remain with it. | |text= While Kingdom Hearts V Cast is not part of the main series of Kingdom Hearts, it is put under the Kingdom Hearts Wiki due to its title. While [[Kingdom Hearts V CAST]] remains a part of this Wiki, any characters, worlds, and the plot should remain with it. | ||
However, while | However, while Caterpillar is an extremely small stub, I feel that a ''"characters"'' section should be added to [[Kingdom Hearts V CAST]], and Caterpillar placed under it. | ||
}} | }} | ||
[[User:Lt.Haven|Lt.Haven]] 22:40, 22 March 2009 (UTC) | [[User:Lt.Haven|Lt.Haven]] 22:40, 22 March 2009 (UTC) | ||
Line 237: | Line 228: | ||
==[[Swordman Island]]== | ==[[Swordman Island]]== | ||
Just because there's little info about V CAST doesn't mean we should delete pages about it. Shouldn't this wiki include info about all things KH? [[User:Myself 123|'''<font color="scarlet">Myself 123</font>''']] 23:37, 19 February 2009 (UTC) | |||
Just because there's little info about V CAST | |||
Yes, my thoughts exactly. Just because it's V-Cast doesn't mean it's not '''Kingdom Hearts''', which means it should remain on the '''Kingdom Hearts''' Wiki. [[User:Xahno|Xahno]] 00:03, 20 February 2009 (UTC) | Yes, my thoughts exactly. Just because it's V-Cast doesn't mean it's not '''Kingdom Hearts''', which means it should remain on the '''Kingdom Hearts''' Wiki. [[User:Xahno|Xahno]] 00:03, 20 February 2009 (UTC) | ||
Line 246: | Line 236: | ||
{{Guardian Soul|text=I agree that V CAST should be included on this wiki, however I think that all of the content should be placed on that one page, since V CAST is not an official Kingdom Hearts game. There isn't even that much information, so why not keep it there?}} | {{Guardian Soul|text=I agree that V CAST should be included on this wiki, however I think that all of the content should be placed on that one page, since V CAST is not an official Kingdom Hearts game. There isn't even that much information, so why not keep it there?}} | ||
That's | That's doesn't seem like a bad idea. [[User:Myself 123|'''<font color="scarlet">Myself 123</font>''']] 21:31, 26 February 2009 (UTC) | ||
{{BebopKate|text=Good call, Guardian Soul. I would go one step further and actually add a redirect to the V CAST article instead of deleting it completely.}} | {{BebopKate|text=Good call, Guardian Soul. I would go one step further and actually add a redirect to the V CAST article instead of deleting it completely.}} | ||
{{BebopKate|text=Same deal as Caterpillar; if someone will archive this at V CAST, I will delete it.}} | {{BebopKate|text=Same deal as Caterpillar; if someone will archive this at V CAST, I will delete it.}} | ||
== | == Diablo, Malificent's Raven '''''and''''' Maleficent's Group== | ||
{{MM841||We already have a page about diablo}} | {{MM841||We already have a page about diablo}} | ||
{{TNE|shocktext=Speaking of which........ There's a page set up by an unknown IP address called | {{TNE|shocktext=Speaking of which........ There's a page set up by an unknown IP address called Maleficent's group. Firstly, the grammar's out. Secondly, we have separate info for the Disney villains, as well as a '''template''' to go with that. Think we should have that page removed ? Or what ? | ||
The grammer was perfect! | The grammer was perfect! | ||
Line 262: | Line 252: | ||
{{TalkTextTest2 | {{TalkTextTest2 | ||
|image= | |image=Marluxia (Talk sprite) 3 KHCOM.png|95px]] | ||
|color=hotpink | |color=hotpink | ||
|color2=black | |color2=black | ||
Line 272: | Line 262: | ||
|sig= I shall scatter your hearts to the empty winds! | |sig= I shall scatter your hearts to the empty winds! | ||
|time= The Warped Master | |time= The Warped Master | ||
|text= Yes, | |text= Yes, Diablo, Malificent's Raven is unnecessary with Diablo. I agree. Maleficent isn't even spelled correctly. | ||
On the subject of TroisNyxÉtienne's objection to | On the subject of TroisNyxÉtienne's objection to Maleficent's group, I seem to recall an article '''''extremely''''' similar to Maleficent's group, only it went under the article name of The Hellfire Club, or simply Hellfire Club. While it is a group, yes, it has no apparent name, and a fandom-crazed Anonymous probably through it up here for lulz. | ||
But seeing as this is an article for deleting | But seeing as this is an article for deleting Diablo, Malificent's Raven, perhaps we should move the conversation to Talk:Maleficent's group. Agreed? | ||
}} | }} | ||
[[User:Lt.Haven|Lt.Haven]] 22:41, 22 March 2009 (UTC) | [[User:Lt.Haven|Lt.Haven]] 22:41, 22 March 2009 (UTC) | ||
Line 293: | Line 283: | ||
{{TalkTextTest2 | {{TalkTextTest2 | ||
|image= | |image=Marluxia (Talk sprite) 3 KHCOM.png|95px]] | ||
|color=hotpink | |color=hotpink | ||
|color2=black | |color2=black | ||
Line 306: | Line 296: | ||
}} | }} | ||
{{TNE|shocktext=What, in the [[ | {{TNE|shocktext=What, in the [[KHWiki:Realm of Nothingness|Realm of Nothingness]] ?}} | ||
{{Guardian Soul|text=I say get rid of it. All of the information on Maleficent's group can easily be added to the articles of the actual members.}} | {{Guardian Soul|text=I say get rid of it. All of the information on Maleficent's group can easily be added to the articles of the actual members.}} | ||
Line 317: | Line 307: | ||
{{Lt.Haven|text=No, on my comp as a .txt}} | {{Lt.Haven|text=No, on my comp as a .txt}} | ||
I made some major improvements to the page some time ago, so obviously I'd rather it stuck around. Besides, I think having a page about the group itself is harmless, and since they were organized, I don't think scattering | I made some major improvements to the page some time ago, so obviously I'd rather it stuck around. Besides, I think having a page about the group itself is harmless, and since they were organized, I don't think scattering they info on the page to the individual's pages is a good idea. Especially considering that the member list may expand in the coming games. [[Special:Contributions/69.207.151.166|69.207.151.166]] 03:34, 26 March 2009 (UTC) | ||
Yay! Another supporter! | Yay! Another supporter! | ||
Line 344: | Line 334: | ||
== Fr:Utilisateur:Zoro-XI == | == Fr:Utilisateur:Zoro-XI == | ||
{{Templat:Zoro-XI|text=Can somebody please delete this article? http://kingdomhearts.wikia.com/wiki/Fr:Utilisateur:Zoro-XI}} | {{Templat:Zoro-XI|text=Can somebody please delete this article? http://kingdomhearts.wikia.com/wiki/Fr:Utilisateur:Zoro-XI}} | ||
Line 360: | Line 349: | ||
EDIT : Please ? And in case you can't see the link in Zoro-XI's page, it's http://kingdomhearts.wikia.com/wiki/Fr:Utilisateur:Zoro-XI}} | EDIT : Please ? And in case you can't see the link in Zoro-XI's page, it's http://kingdomhearts.wikia.com/wiki/Fr:Utilisateur:Zoro-XI}} | ||
== | == Across Two == | ||
{{MM841||No conten on the page, and i am pretty sure it has nothing to do with KH.}} | {{MM841||No conten on the page, and i am pretty sure it has nothing to do with KH.}} | ||
:I think it is actually a mistook grammar error for the Keyblade, [[Two Across]]. [[User:Evilgidgit|Evilgidgit]] 22:19, 26 March 2009 (UTC) | :I think it is actually a mistook grammar error for the Keyblade, [[Two Across]]. [[User:Evilgidgit|Evilgidgit]] 22:19, 26 March 2009 (UTC) | ||
Line 369: | Line 358: | ||
{{TNE|text=Backwards talking meant I. Count didn't voice passive know didn't I.}} | {{TNE|text=Backwards talking meant I. Count didn't voice passive know didn't I.}} | ||
== | == Grasshopper, Earthworm, Miss Spider, The Glowworm == | ||
{{MM841||All rumours that probably wont be in BBS, and even if they are, they sound like small roles}} | {{MM841||All rumours that probably wont be in BBS, and even if they are, they sound like small roles}} | ||
{{TalkTextTest2 | {{TalkTextTest2 | ||
|image= | |image=Marluxia (Talk sprite) 3 KHCOM.png|95px]] | ||
|color=hotpink | |color=hotpink | ||
|color2=black | |color2=black | ||
Line 387: | Line 376: | ||
{{BebopKate|text=*forehead* I got rid of those not long ago. Here we go again...}} | {{BebopKate|text=*forehead* I got rid of those not long ago. Here we go again...}} | ||
{{Yer mom|text=There's also a | {{Yer mom|text=There's also a James one...}} | ||
==Pages for moving/deletion ?== | ==Pages for moving/deletion ?== | ||
{{TNE|text=Okay. There are two pages done by [[User:Sonicsponge111]] and they fall under Mainspace. Both of them are strategy guides, which'd sound redundant considering that each enemy page already has its Strategy bit. Plus, those posts are rather poorly written. Methinks they should be deleted, or moved to pages with the prefix '''User:'''. | {{TNE|text=Okay. There are two pages done by [[User:Sonicsponge111]] and they fall under Mainspace. Both of them are strategy guides, which'd sound redundant considering that each enemy page already has its Strategy bit. Plus, those posts are rather poorly written. Methinks they should be deleted, or moved to pages with the prefix '''User:'''. | ||
They're | They're http://kingdomhearts.wikia.com/wiki/Sonicsponge111/_Reverse/Rebirth_Mode Sonicsponge111/Reverse/Rebirth Mode and Sonicsponge111/KH2 Strategy Guide. And I fear that there could be an extra page hiding. Think you could help take them out for me (or at the very least, move them to where they should be placed) ?}} | ||
{{Xiggie|text=I think that it can stay (it's on his | {{Xiggie|text=I think that it can stay (it's on his user page area)... | ||
just wondering, If we rewrite it, couldn't we place it under Kingdom Hears II/strategy guide? | just wondering, If we rewrite it, couldn't we place it under Kingdom Hears II/strategy guide? | ||
Line 399: | Line 388: | ||
EDIT: on second thought, nah...}} | EDIT: on second thought, nah...}} | ||
{{TNE|text=It isn't in his User area. It's under Mainspace if you look carefully. A | {{TNE|text=It isn't in his User area. It's under Mainspace if you look carefully. A user page-area article would begin with '''User:Sonicsponge111/Reverse/Rebirth Mode''' and not '''Sonicsponge111/Reverse/Rebirth Mode'''. The whole difference between Mainspace and User articles is this prefix '''User:'''.}} | ||
{{Xiggie|surprised=Oh, I didn't notice. well, let's notify [[User:Sonicsponge111|him]] and get those two pages moved to '''User:Sonicsponge111/KH2 Strategy Guide''' and '''User:Sonicsponge111/Reverse/Rebirth Mode'''...}} | {{Xiggie|surprised=Oh, I didn't notice. well, let's notify [[User:Sonicsponge111|him]] and get those two pages moved to '''User:Sonicsponge111/KH2 Strategy Guide''' and '''User:Sonicsponge111/Reverse/Rebirth Mode'''...}} | ||
Line 405: | Line 394: | ||
{{BebopKate|text=I just went ahead and moved them to his User area, and took care of the rest.}} | {{BebopKate|text=I just went ahead and moved them to his User area, and took care of the rest.}} | ||
{{TNE|text=Another page from Sonicsponge111 came into the mainspace : [[Dustin's friends]]. Please help move them into the | {{TNE|text=Another page from Sonicsponge111 came into the mainspace : [[Dustin's friends]]. Please help move them into the user page area... | ||
Meanwhile, I approached him at his talk page and tried explaining to him about beginning his pages with '''User:Sonicsponge111/'''--. I hope he understands. If he doesn't, anyone around here, please help me. | Meanwhile, I approached him at his talk page and tried explaining to him about beginning his pages with '''User:Sonicsponge111/'''--. I hope he understands. If he doesn't, anyone around here, please help me. | ||
Line 413: | Line 402: | ||
EDIT : Moved. (Wokay. I didn't know '''I''' could move pages.)}} | EDIT : Moved. (Wokay. I didn't know '''I''' could move pages.)}} | ||
== | ==Sora & Kairi's Kiss== | ||
{{Xiggie|text=It's back up again! the text is very stubby and the image is obviously photoshoped! | {{Xiggie|text=It's back up again! the text is very stubby and the image is obviously photoshoped! | ||
Line 430: | Line 419: | ||
I'm sure our mentor on KHWiki would have much more patience to deal with this. (Which reminds me... I need more patience.)}} | I'm sure our mentor on KHWiki would have much more patience to deal with this. (Which reminds me... I need more patience.)}} | ||
{{BebopKate|text='''Deleted''' and protected for now. And Xiggie, everyone knows that it's actually | {{BebopKate|text='''Deleted''' and protected for now. And Xiggie, everyone knows that it's actually {{w|Portal (video game)|the cake}} that's a lie. ^_^}} | ||
{{TNE|shocktext=Huh... what cake ?}} | {{TNE|shocktext=Huh... what cake ?}} | ||
{{Guardian Soul|text='''The''' cake.}} | {{Guardian Soul|text='''The''' cake.}} |
Latest revision as of 00:44, 13 April 2022
This is an archive page for deletion discussions on the Kingdom Hearts Wiki for January, February, and March 2009. These discussions are considered closed. Please bring up any further issues on the current deletions page.
Disorganizationxiii[edit]
I think Disorganizationxiii needs to be Deletion. its fan stuff. so I'll leave you guys to remove itEliskuya2 17:37, 25 January 2009 (UTC)
I object. It's really the best out of all parodies out there and clearly deserves its own wiki. It's not really fan stuff. If it were fan stuff, it would just be somebody saying, "I LOVE ORGANIZATION XIII!" or just put random pics and facts about kingdom hearts on the page. It's an official series that should be kept here. Please. I worked forever on that page.
- We don't do fan works here, unless it's on a user page. And even then, we're not big fans of shameless self-promotion. Deleted. BebopKate 02:15, 26 January 2009 (UTC)
well its up again bebop can we just block things like thatEliskuya2 04:18, 26 January 2009 (UTC)
|
they need to make a wiki for all fan things etc. and I hope this time it gets deletionEliskuya2 04:47, 26 January 2009 (UTC)
|
yeah let my friend bebop duel with it. and troisnyxetienne come to my page if you need some hints on KHEliskuya2 16:53, 26 January 2009 (UTC)
XienZo got it the other two times. Protected now, and if it somehow reappears, the poster is banned. BebopKate 02:23, 27 January 2009 (UTC)
if I see an other I well late you guys duel with it peaceEliskuya2 02:51, 27 January 2009 (UTC)
|
- Today. It's protected, so we should be fine for now. BebopKate 04:05, 27 January 2009 (UTC)
its back and I find who makes the thing its DISORGANIZATIONXIIILOVER Eliskuya2 21:12, 27 January 2009 (UTC)
|
I am with you troisnyxetEliskuya2 05:12, 1 February 2009 (UTC)
He's posting under multiple IPs, so we can only ban the IPs he posts under and block the article names. If this continues, I will alert the Wikia admins to help us out. In the meantime, just post here to let XienZo or me know to delete and keep wiking away as normal. I have also alerted the Disorganization XIII people to keep our bases covered. Just console yourself that you have more of a life than this guy does. ^_^ BebopKate 05:42, 1 February 2009 (UTC)
|
I think if I see an other again block the user and the site to the "Disorganizationxiii" thing as well and good night brother Bebop and sister TroisnyxeEliskuya2 11:25, 1 February 2009 (UTC)
|
Only admins have the power to block users, so right now it's mostly me and XienZo doing the job. And we can only block them if they have one IP address or a username. If they are posting from multiple IPs like some of our more famous past trolls have done, there's really nothing we can do other than block the IPs they are using and protect the pages. Wikia is working on a way to block people who abuse IPs, but it's a long way off in getting done. The only thing we can do at the moment is what we've been doing: revert, protect, and ban. For the record, I think you guys are doing a wonderful job of fixing and keeping up with these things; it's been a huge help to me and XienZo. Just be patient and understand that with the good of the wiki (free editing) comes the bad (vandalizing jerks and trolls).
By the way, I feel this needs to be said: DO NOT SPAM OR DOWNVOTE THE DISORGANIZATION XIII YOUTUBE CHANNEL! The people behind it are not the ones who are doing this; I have been in contact with them. It is one of their fans. They are looking around on their end and have made it clear they are not any happier about it than we are, and have apologized for it. I hope whoever has been doing this realizes the potential damage he or she is doing to something they apparently enjoy. BebopKate 18:30, 1 February 2009 (UTC)
|
There's a page called TroisNyxEtienneText, under templates[edit]
|
- Got it. Thanks for letting us know. ^_^ BebopKate 05:18, 31 January 2009 (UTC)
|
Arch Behemoth and Destroyed Behemoth[edit]
|
If that's the case, definitely. I'd only make another page if the stats and abilities were different. A redirect from Arch Behemoth and Destroyed Behemoth would be a good idea, too. BebopKate 21:08, 8 February 2009 (UTC)
|
|
|
|
|
- As of now, the Behemoth article does not mention Arc or Destroyed Behemoth's at all, and in fact incorrectly reports that regular Behemoth's were seen in the 1000 Heartless battle. Before any deletions occur, how about the sections be merged first?
- A the Digimon Wiki, we've had a similar problem, and we've dealt with it with a middle ground between the two positions advocated here. As seen in articles like this one, each version of a "type" of enemy is given a section in the page - kind of like a list article. This method could also be applied to Red Nocturne types, so that there's not too much hair-splitting and argumentation - all of that "type" of enemy is in one article, but each gets its own section. So, Soldiers and Stealth Soldiers would be on one page, all five types of mushrooms, etc. The only problem then is figuring out a name for the entire article - I would suggest Behemoth Heartless, Wizard Heartless (as the rhapsodies/nocturnes are all said to be a subset of Wizard class), Soldier Heartless, Mushroom Heartless, etc. (or some version of that naming scheme). This way, you could
- Get rid of short, stubby articles, by changing them into short sections of a larger page
- Allow readers to directly and easily compare variations of a central theme
- Allow editors to see how the other sections are formatted, allowing for greater unity of article design between similar enemies.
- Really, the only problem with this approach is determining the name of the merged article, but that shouldn't be too hard.Not even Mr. Lister's Koromon survived intact. 20:20, 20 February 2009 (UTC)
|
|
|
|
Cerberus (Enemy)[edit]
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Narnia[edit]
|
ED Pills[edit]
|
Template:Radiant Garden[edit]
|
Images[edit]
All of the images listed for deletion are superseded files that have been replaced with cleaner images and standardized names. Please delete them.Not even Mr. Lister's Koromon survived intact. 23:36, 5 March 2009 (UTC)
Detection Saber[edit]
|
|
Agreed. Deleted. BebopKate 01:22, 11 March 2009 (UTC)
The language-0 templates[edit]
|
|
Arch Wyvern[edit]
|
|
|
|
|
|
Heart of destany[edit]
|
Sigh...not him again. Deleted BebopKate 22:55, 22 March 2009 (UTC)
Plane Crazy[edit]
|
Yup. Not needed; a Wikipedia link would work just fine anyway. Deleted BebopKate 22:56, 22 March 2009 (UTC)
Category:Weapon Card Images[edit]
|
|
Sora & Kairi's kiss ?[edit]
|
|
Image and article Deleted. BebopKate 01:34, 25 March 2009 (UTC)
There's a page called Category:Secret drive form[edit]
|
|
|
|
Xevents[edit]
|
|
Caterpillar[edit]
I don't think that characters or places from V Cast should have their own articles, seeing as V Cast isn't canon to the series and is more like a side thing, such as manga or the KH card game. Everything from V Cast should be kept in that one article. Guardian Soul 07:21, 14 January 2009 (UTC)
|
- Agreed, i had no idea the character exsisted in the KH Universe, which V cast isnt really, but also kind of is just not really cannonical but it has a good image, maybe there isnt a lot of info but theres pages out there with a lot less and there still there. I say we keep it.
- V Cast or not, it's a game made of Kingdom Hearts. Though it's unofficial, it is part of the KH universe.
|
Lt.Haven 22:40, 22 March 2009 (UTC)
|
Swordman Island[edit]
Just because there's little info about V CAST doesn't mean we should delete pages about it. Shouldn't this wiki include info about all things KH? Myself 123 23:37, 19 February 2009 (UTC)
Yes, my thoughts exactly. Just because it's V-Cast doesn't mean it's not Kingdom Hearts, which means it should remain on the Kingdom Hearts Wiki. Xahno 00:03, 20 February 2009 (UTC)
I totally agree on that. Charmed-Jay, 23 February, 2009
|
That's doesn't seem like a bad idea. Myself 123 21:31, 26 February 2009 (UTC)
|
|
Diablo, Malificent's Raven and Maleficent's Group[edit]
|
|
|
Lt.Haven 22:41, 22 March 2009 (UTC)
Give me a break! It was my second article. P.S. I am not just some "fandom-crazed Anonymous".
|
I never wrote Male Ficent, I proofread!
|
Thank you! It's good to see that SOMEONE has some sense around here.
|
|
|
People would rather just have it all on one page!
|
Well I did, jerk!
|
I made some major improvements to the page some time ago, so obviously I'd rather it stuck around. Besides, I think having a page about the group itself is harmless, and since they were organized, I don't think scattering they info on the page to the individual's pages is a good idea. Especially considering that the member list may expand in the coming games. 69.207.151.166 03:34, 26 March 2009 (UTC)
Yay! Another supporter!
|
Make a better name yourself.
What's that supposed to mean?
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Fr:Utilisateur:Zoro-XI[edit]
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Across Two[edit]
|
- I think it is actually a mistook grammar error for the Keyblade, Two Across. Evilgidgit 22:19, 26 March 2009 (UTC)
|
|
|
|
|
Grasshopper, Earthworm, Miss Spider, The Glowworm[edit]
|
|
|
|
Pages for moving/deletion ?[edit]
|
|
|
|
|
|
Sora & Kairi's Kiss[edit]
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|