Template talk:Worlds: Difference between revisions

From the Kingdom Hearts Wiki, the Kingdom Hearts encyclopedia
Jump to navigationJump to search
Line 46: Line 46:
:;My argument
:;My argument
You're right, it's not included in the main story and has no involvement with Square-Enix, but it's still a part of the series. The V Cast may be impopular, but since Swordman Island is a world introduced in a game that's still involved with the Kingdom Hearts games. Just the [[Caterpillar]].
You're right, it's not included in the main story and has no involvement with Square-Enix, but it's still a part of the series. The V Cast may be impopular, but since Swordman Island is a world introduced in a game that's still involved with the Kingdom Hearts games. Just the [[Caterpillar]].
{{KrytenKoro|Instead of using "introduced" (which has Radiant Garden in KH1, for example), why not just list the worlds that appear in each, like we do with bosses or keyblades?
Yen Sid's Tower is listed as a separate world from Twilight Town in [[Director's Secret Report XIII]].
If Hollow Bastion gets to have both names, Halloween Town should have both names. They each get their own costume, I would say that's as close to a dual-world as we can get. Same with Underworld, if it is ever actually called a "world" in the game. The Coliseum does not include the Underworld, so one name shouldn't apply to both.
For Swordsman Island and the BBS worlds, why don't we have a "Other Worlds" bit for those worlds that have not been officially released, or don't really have their own section?
Does anyone think it would be a good idea to have a version of this that organizes them by realm? Light, In-between, Darkness? I could even set it up so that you can switch between versions by clicking a button}}

Revision as of 19:21, 10 March 2009

How the world template should look.

The correct layout for worlds right now should be as followed:

Worlds introduced in Kingdom Hearts:

Destiny Islands | Disney Castle | Wonderland | Deep Jungle | Olympus Coliseum | Agrabah | 100 Acre Wood | Monstro | Atlantica | Halloween Town | Neverland | Hollow Bastion/Radiant Garden | End of the World

Worlds introduced in Kingdom Hearts: Chain of Memories:

Twilight Town | Castle Oblivion

Worlds introduced in Kingdom Hearts II:

The Land of Dragons | Beast's Castle | Timeless River | Sunset Horizons | Port Royal | Pride Lands | Space Paranoids | The World That Never Was

Worlds introduced in Kingdom Hearts: Birth by Sleep:

Snow White's House | Enchanted Dominion | Castle of Dreams

This way, the worlds template is clean and simple. Worlds that are introduced should be named during the game of introduction. "The World That Never Was" did show up in the KH1 secret ending, but was only named in KHII, so it should be kept in the KHII section.


I also think I should note that some places being added to the list of worlds have no business being there.

Christmas Town:

Already part of Halloween Town, It's not a world all on It's own, so it shouldn't be included.

Underworld:

Already part of Olympus Coliseum, just another area added, but connected to the same world.

Yen Sid's Tower:

Currently part of Twilight Town, shouldn't be included as an extra world.

Swordman Island:

The world added to Kingdom Hearts V CAST. This was put into a game that had no involvement with Square Enix at all, and isn't even canon to the series, definately should be excluded.

Also, even though Hollow Bastion got renamed Radiant Garden in KHII, It's still the same world, so it should be written under the "Worlds introduced in Kingdom Hearts" section, and just put down as "Hollow Bastion/Radiant Garden".

I think the reasons for this list are valid, and that the template should be kept like this, unless of course, new worlds are announced. If anything else should be added, I think that the person who hopes to add that area should bring up a good reason beforehand, because this really should be the final list for now.

My argument

You're right, it's not included in the main story and has no involvement with Square-Enix, but it's still a part of the series. The V Cast may be impopular, but since Swordman Island is a world introduced in a game that's still involved with the Kingdom Hearts games. Just the Caterpillar.


209.png
KrytenKoro - "An education was a bit like a communicable sexual disease. It made you unsuitable for a lot of jobs and then you had the urge to pass it on."
TALK -
Instead of using "introduced" (which has Radiant Garden in KH1, for example), why not just list the worlds that appear in each, like we do with bosses or keyblades?

Yen Sid's Tower is listed as a separate world from Twilight Town in Director's Secret Report XIII.

If Hollow Bastion gets to have both names, Halloween Town should have both names. They each get their own costume, I would say that's as close to a dual-world as we can get. Same with Underworld, if it is ever actually called a "world" in the game. The Coliseum does not include the Underworld, so one name shouldn't apply to both.

For Swordsman Island and the BBS worlds, why don't we have a "Other Worlds" bit for those worlds that have not been officially released, or don't really have their own section?

Does anyone think it would be a good idea to have a version of this that organizes them by realm? Light, In-between, Darkness? I could even set it up so that you can switch between versions by clicking a button