Editing Talk:Nobody

{{Bluer|01:02, 21 March 2008 (UTC)|I've seen the edit war in this page, kupo, and I'm not pleased. Someone please reorganize the Types section because I frankly have no idea how it is actually organized,}}

Have you ever nocticed that heartless are made from peoples hearts, and nobodies are made from peoples bodies? I bet the unbirths are made from born people. [[User:Myself 123|'''<font color="scarlet">Myself 123</font>''']] 20:36, 16 October 2008 (UTC)

==Emotions==
I know its said many times throughout KH2 that nobodies have no emotions, but I feel like its an arguable fact.  Yen Sid says it, and DiZ says it all the time, but the story seems to be trying to convince you otherwise.  Roxas and Axel clearly actually care for eachother, otherwise Axel's actions make no sense.  Namine is a Nobody, and yet she cares enough about Sora and Roxas to try to save them.  Is it possible that these generalizations are just DiZ being sort of a "racist"?--[[User:Zephyrus11|Zephyrus11]] 08:42, 30 March 2008 (UTC)
:Not racist, but perhaps he was implying that since Nobody's are in actual bodies and souls without hearts, they would not have emotions. Yet sometimes I believe we don't need hearts to have emotion, memories could also trigger emotions. [[User:Bluerfn|[^_]][[User talk:Bluerfn|^]/]] 08:44, 30 March 2008 (UTC)
::Actually, it's a convertion screw-up. As I recall, it's only in the NA and EU version that it is actually directly stated in the story by charcters that Nobodies do not have emotions ''at all''. In the Jap version, they were merely called "incomplete", an did, to some extent, retain bits and pieces of emotions. At least that was the gist of it, I think. I'll try to find where I read that, just to be sure. --[[User:Hecko X|Hecko X]] 10:38, 30 March 2008 (UTC)
:::Why hasn't this been added in, then? The article still clearly says Nobodies lack emotions and emotions they do show are used to trick others. Even not considering Axel and his sacrifice, Larxene shows regret and disbelief when she fades and Vexen begs Axel for his life. That's pretty clear fear, and who would Vexen be fooling when Axel is a Nobody as well? Saix goes into a berserk rage when he fights Sora. While there are some examples of Nobodies faking emotions, examples like this seem to show that Nobodies do have some measure of emotions, despite observations of certain characters in the game.
::::Heh, its very likely that Nomura came up with the emotionless nobodies concept AFTER CoM, so he initially designed them with vibrant personalities. He'll have to find some excuse in 358/2 days that proves that they really were emotionless most of the time. But yeah, so far, he's consistantly claimed that they have no emotions. He claims that things like Vexen begging and stuff are the nobodies becoming so good a pretending they have emotions that they are fooling themselves. [[User:XienZo|XienZo]] 18:07, 27 December 2008 (UTC)
:::::I'm not sure he came up with that concept after CoM. After all, Twilight Town, Roxas, the Xemnas/Xehanort/DiZ conundrum, and the concept of Nobodies had already been created. Kingdom Hearts II was clearly pretty far into development by that point. But if you think about it, remember- Nobodies remember their past lives. Therefore, they remember what it was like to have a heart, and feelings, even if they no longer do. Since in Kingdom Hearts, "heart" means something more along the lines of "soul," Nobodies are more like memories of their past lives in a physical form. They aren't pretending to have feelings to trick others- it's so they feel they still have a purpose in life, a coping mechanism to deal with their miserable "non-existence." (Not to push the "racist" angle, but a similar concept is in the book "Invisible Man," in which the main character begins to feel like he doesn't exist, and he strikes out at others to prove his existence to himself.) And who, after their death, wouldn't give anything to return to life? Even without a soul or feelings, they would long to be complete again. That explains their primary goal, AND why they fear death- dying means they can never go back to their old lives. In the end, it's just another term that shouldn't be taken too literally, like the idea of them actually "not existing." Obviously, they "exist," but only on a PHYSICAL plane. They "don't exist" in the sense that they have no metaphysical quality, no soul or "heart" to give them a HUMAN existence.

== Playable! ==

Marluxia and Demyx and these other guys are playabe in Kingdom Hearts 2? I Guess I've Been Missing Out

{{Twoface13|Who put this here? As far as I know, you can't play as anyone other than Sora, Riku, and Mickey without the use of a cheating device. Are you referring to the multiplayer part of 358/2 Days?|}}

{{TNE|text=Heck, yeah, I guess he's referring to Days.}}

==Disney Characters==
I wonder if Claton and/or Scar became Nobodies... [[User:Mcoolister|Mcoolister]]
:Possible, but i think Clayton had a weak will so he probily became a lesser Nobody, you might have already killed it. As for Scar, i'm not sure about that. [[User:Myself 123|'''<font color="scarlet">Myself 123</font>''']] 18:01, 3 November 2008 (UTC)
::Scar probably had a Nobody, yeah. I'm also concerned as to the identities of Organization XIII's Heartless, and whether or not Riku or his replica could have a Nobody, as both were technically consumed by darkness at one point or another. Of course, neither Scar or Clayton were strong enough to be turned into distinctive Nobodies. Just watch their respective movies if you need proof of that. :P

==Just a completely random thought==

I have a picture of Terra, Ven and Aqua, all together in a row, really cool looking and everything, and I noticed all three of them have a symbol somewhere on their clothes that resembles the Nobody logo, but is right-side up, the heart has a different way of looking and the three points are more spiked. I was shocked when I noticed so I just had to check it and post SOMETHING...

All I have to say now is...thoughts anyone? [[User:Leiber_Mage]]

:Can you show me?

[[image:Birth_by_Sleep_group_shot.jpg]]

That's the picture that I mean. The three emblems on their uniforms resemble the nobody logo but upside down. [[User:Leiber_Mage]]
:Looks more like a spiky Heartless Emblem to me. But at this point, it could mean anything, so for the time being, instead of making random theories, it would be more fruitful to just keep an eye out for official info concerning this issue. Nice job in noticing though. --[[User:Hecko X|Hecko X]] 18:26, 21 December 2008 (UTC)

The symbols are actually hearts -_-[[User:Sxoxpxhxixe|Sxoxpxhxixe]] 18:33, 21 December 2008 (UTC)

Hmmm, how come Terra's emblem is in a different plance than the others it's also gold instead of silver. [[User:Myself 123|'''<font color="scarlet">Myself 123</font>''']] 23:18, 22 January 2009 (UTC)
:Because he wants people to look at his crotch. It's like those guys who wear big golden belt buckles.

== Pureblood ? ==

{{unbirthtalk|text=I've always wondered, could be there "Pureblood" nobodies ? All the nobodies we've seen so far in the series wore the emblem. It's logically the Organization who put it on them, but how are nobodies without it ? Are the organization members the only nobodies born "naturally", the others being created like the emblem heartless ?}}

{{TNE|text=Lemme think... Wait, Dusks and Creepers don't have Emblems on them, do they ? And considering that they are the Nobody equivalents of Pureblood Heartless (Neoshadows and Shadows respectively), methinks they're "Pureblood" in their own right. As for the rest, I can assume they were created.}}

{{unbirthtalk|text=They do have the emblem, the Dusk on its head and the Creeper on its "hands".}}

{{Xiggie|text=Yeah, they have the emblem...

but when you think about it, Dusks and Creepers are the only nobodies who aren't under a "master"... like Roxas has the Samurais, Demyx has the Dancers and Saïx has the Berserkers...

also, I was wandering if there were more (emblem) Nobodies, one kind for every Org. member... one type for Vexen, another for Lexaeus, Zexion, Larxene and Marluxia... think they'll be revealed in KH days?}}

{{unbirthtalk|text=I don't really think, we haven't seen any lesser nobody in any video or scan.}}

{{Xiggie|text=True, but still... I hope... :P}}
{{KrytenKoro|Non-human Nobodies are divided into "low-ranking" and "high-ranking", instead of "Pureblood" and "Emblem". Honestly, I always thought that Sorcerers worked much better for Zexion, Tiamat for Xemnas, Spectre for Marluxia, Creeper for Vexen (shield form), Twilight Thorn for Lexaeus (biggest, slamming attacks), and Dusk for Larxene (slinky). There's exactly 13 non-gummi Nobodies, but whatever, Nomura...but hopefully in 358/2 or some version of KH3, the last few Nobodies will be placed.

If Tiamat isn't Xemnas' servant, is it a "low-ranking" Nobody?}}

{{TNE|shocktext=Tiamat ? Wait a minute : refresh me on that one.

Unbirth : Oops ! My bad ! Or what if... there '''are''' Purebloods, and Emblem Nobodies, and all of them have actually been inscribed with the Nobody symbol by their masters, Organisation XIII, as a sign of allegiance ?}}

I think "tiamat" is the big dragon xemnas commands in the final boss

{{Doc rocco|time=00:55, 10 May 2009 (UTC)|shocktext=Well, if you think about the manner in which Nobodies are created, I don't think the Organization has the means to create them; a Heartless needs a heart while a Nobody needs a '''strong''' heart, body and soul. I don't think the Organization would be able to replicate the last two, personally, but then again, it is KH. 

I regardless of that, I think that all Nobodies are Pureblood in that sense.}}
{{KrytenKoro|Oh! Sorry. Yeah, Tiamat is generally the name of the ultimate evil dragon in the FF series, and seeing as almost all other Nobodies are named after FF jobs, either that or Bahamut would be a likely name for the thing.}}

== Some thoughts on nobodies ==

I had a weird thought when Axel said I'm not getting turned into a dusk for this that the orgazation has power to change human nobodies to dusks or a lower class of nobodies.--[[User:Firaga44|Firaga44]] 01:55, 30 May 2009 (UTC)
{{Firaga44|text=ok let me see if i can get my facts straight.Nobodies don't have hearts.
Each member of orgazation 13 commands a certain nobody}}.

{{NinjaSheik|text=That's correct, so far.}}

i think there is plenty of room for a heartless organization and a new type of enemy
thoughts please:

{{Bro01|text=if the strong nobodies still have a human appearance, what crates the big ones like the twilight thorn? are they 'animal' nobodies or something?}}
@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
-==Merge in==
-<pre>{{game|358|COM|REC}}
-{{merge|Replica}}
-The '''Replica Program''' was a planned series of experiments conducted by [[Vexen]] under [[Xemnas]]'s orders, with the apparent help of [[Naminé]]. He attempted to make [[Replica]]s of [[Keyblade]] wielders [[Sora]] and [[Riku]] in the event that the original Sora proved to be useless to his plans for [[Kingdom Hearts]]. The first replica created by the program was [[Xion]].<ref>Xion's name is an anagram for "No ''i''"</ref> However, after Xion's defection and her death by [[Roxas]], Xemnas discontinued the program. In the [[Secret Reports]] it mentions [[Riku Replica|another inferior numberless replica]] that was taken to [[Castle Oblivion]]. The Secret Reports in ''[[Kingdom Hearts 358/2 Days]]'' also reveal the existence of other unused replicas.
-==Gallery==
-<gallery>
-File:Riku Replica KH.png|The Riku Replica, created from the real Riku's combat data
-File:Xion KHD.png|Xion, an imperfect Replica of Roxas that resembles Kairi (Sora's most important and strongest memory)
-</gallery>
-{{-}}
-{{NobodyDirectory}}
-{{358}}
-{{COM}}
-{{KH series}}
-[[Category:Replica]]
-==Products==
-===Xion===
-[[File:Xion KHD.png|thumb|150px|right|Xion, the first product of the Replica Program]]
-Xion was created by Vexen out of Sora's memories. She held these memories which would stop Sora from being able to awaken from his slumber. Xion, being made out of Sora's memories, could wield a Keyblade, something [[Organization XIII]] wanted. This would make it so Organization XIII had two among their ranks that could wield the Keyblade and collect hearts to form Kingdom Hearts. She was seen by some as only a puppet, while only Roxas and [[Axel]] called her a friend. She was destroyed by Roxas, and the program was stopped shortly after her defeat.
-===Riku Replica===
-[[File:Riku Replica KH.png|thumb|120px|left|The Riku Replica, the only other known product of the Replica Program]]
-The [[Riku Replica]] was created shortly after Xion was created by Vexen. He created this replica after sampling the real Riku's memories. Vexen used this replica to fight both Sora and Riku. The Riku Replica always knew he was the fake one, but always fought to get rid of Riku, what the Organization wanted. He met his demise by Riku, and was swallowed by the darkness after being defeated.
-==Notes and references==
-{{reflist|1}}
-{{-}}
-{{stub}}
-{{COM}}
-{{358}}
-[[Category:Replica]]
-[[Category:Kingdom Hearts: Chain of Memories]]
-[[Category:Kingdom Hearts 358/2 Days]]
-</pre>
-==Split off==
-<pre>==[[Reaction Commands]]==
-'''Reversal'''
-Reaction Command available enemy: [[Dusk]], [[Xemnas]]'s & [[Twilight Thorn]]'s Nobody thorn strike.
-*Info: You swing around a Dusk, so that you are facing its back. This also works on Creepers if one is standing nearby, and is used in the battles with Twilight Thorn and Xemnas (fourth incarnation).
-'''Berserk'''
-Reaction Command available enemy: [[Berserker]], [[Saïx]]
-*Info: The weapon of a Berserker is grabbed. Sora can then use it against them and cannot take damage while holding it. This Reaction Command continues on to several upward hits with the hammer, and then a flurry of midair attacks christened "Magna Storm." This move has some type of magnetic effect, causing any enemies close to Sora to be stuck to him, and caught in the attack.
-'''Fail-Safe'''
-Reaction Command available enemy: [[Assassin]]
-*Info: Instantly kills an Assassin by forcing them underground before exploding, rather than having them explode above ground and damage Sora. It also damages nearby enemies and even other Assassins underground.
-'''Warp Snipe'''
-Reaction Command available enemy: [[Sniper]], [[Xigbar]], while trying to snipe you in the tower.
-*Info: Sora teleports and defies gravity by standing sideways in midair and sends a Sniper's bullet back at them. He can teleport and continue knocking the bullet back up to 3 times.
-'''Learn'''
-Reaction Command available enemy: [[Dragoon]], [[Xaldin]]
-*Info: The Attack command changes to Jump, which allows Sora to jump above the enemy's head, then pierce down the enemy targeted with the Keyblade's edge facing downwards. A total of nine Jumps can be stocked. This name is a reference to the skill of the same name attributed to Dragoons in ''Final Fantasy''.
-'''Stop Dice/ Begin Game'''
-Reaction command available enemy: [[Gambler]], [[Luxord]]
-*Info: Sora enters a gambling game with a Gambler. He must hit a certain command at the right moment to win, which will destroy the Nobody and cause a rainfall of [[munny]]. If he gets it wrong, he is turned into a [[Card Form|playing card]] or [[Die Form|rolling die]].
-'''Duel Stance'''
-Reaction Command available enemy: [[Samurai]], [[Roxas]] (''Kingdom Hearts II Final Mix'' only)
-*Info: Sora enters a one-on-one battle with a Samurai, as they both stop attacking and stand motionless, blades at the ready. The command menu goes blank as time slows down. After a few seconds, the command '''The End''' appears randomly in one of the four command slots. If Sora can reach the command in time, he'll do a quick finishing slash that does damage, but if he's too slow, he will take damage from the Samurai's slash.
-**While fighting with Roxas, if Sora selects the right command, he will knock Roxas away and steal his Keyblades, which allows Sora to use them and Roxas's attacks are limited to using his light crosses only until he eventually acquires them back.</pre>
-==Could==
-Could it be possible the other unused replicas mentioned in the Secret reoprts could have been the Data Replicas of Organization XIII in KH Final Mix+? Just a thought. A little research into this, and the information could extend the article.
-:No, not really, since a Replica is a physical thing. The ''Replica Data'' are simply digital recordings of the Organization members.[[User:KrytenKoro|<small>Glorious</small>]] [[User_talk:KrytenKoro|<small>CHAOS!</small>]] 20:06, February 18, 2010 (UTC)
-::Perhaps the Replica Data were planned replicas, in the event of a member's defeat. Vexen could have recorded their battle strategies and made data versions. Maybe he planned to make actual Replicas, but was killed before he could. [[Special:Contributions/66.215.20.249|66.215.20.249]] 04:52, July 18, 2010 (UTC)
-== Deep Jungle ==
-{{CaelumLucisCaliga|time=18:14, July 30, 2010 (UTC)|text=In Deep Jungle, there's a bunch of notes in the campsite that, when you put them together, show you how to make Hi-Potions and Ethers or something. Anyway, I found a different note somewhere that mentioned a Replica Program. Should that be mentioned?}}
-==Whew==
-{{XNamineX|text=*whew* That was fun. The artcle is still missing a few things like flow with the storyline and a few explanations. Also, the grammar probably isn't perfect. So have at it! ^_^}}
-{{TNE|attntext=Question : is the Riku Replica confirmed to be #2 of the Replica project ? Or was it Vexen's creation, outside the sequence ?}}
-{{XNamineX|text=well...acording to the Research Log, they didn't give a number to Riku Replica, so I geuss that means he isn't No.II}}
-== Zexion ==
-{{KrytenKoro|Wait okay.
-When a Replica absorbs a Nobody, the whole being can never come back, can they? That seems to be the deal with Xion and Roxas.
-So, all the Organization except for Zexion where either dispersed (and returned to wherever Nobody bits go while they wait to re-be) or completed (Roxas).
-However, Zexion was absorbed by Ixion.
-) Why didn't Ixion ''become'' the new Ienzo? Xion should have become Sora if she absorbed Roxas, right?
-) So Ienzo is the only one who's buggered?}}
-{{TNE|shocktext=Ixion ?? You mean, Repliku ?}}
-{{Guardian Soul|text=I'm pretty sure Repliku just drained Zexion's life, I don't think he absorbed him.  And what do you mean by "Ixion"?  Xion is made from Sora's memories, she's already a part of Roxas, which is why she can absorb him.}}
-{{TNE|text=I think I understand. If Repliku was the '''actual''' #2 of the Replica Project (which, we're not sure), then he'd be termed No. II. And because he lacks a heart, he'd technically be a Nobody - so add No II with an X and you get Ixion. But then again, didn't Repliku have a heart ? I'm pretty sure he did.}}
-{{NinjaSheik|text=Yes, I think he did have a heart, but I think he said it was fake, right?}}
-{{Guardian Soul|text="Day 23 — Research Log 326
-The plan is nearly going well. Concerning the most superior replica, ‘No.i’, it is going almost too smoothly. The other that we couldn’t aquire a number for was brought to Castle Oblivion, with the plan to do further research with it. These replicas, at least isn’t it okay to call them special nobodies?"}}
-{{NinjaSheik|text=The other repilica, huh? Replica Riku was intended to become a member? Hmm...}}
-It's probably been realized that, obviously, the Riku Replica is NOT No.2, and that makes sense. After all, he was made for a
-completely different purpose than Xion. Vexen made him in order to counter Sora and destroy Marluxia's plan to try and overthrow
-the Organization. Xion, on the other hand, was made specifically by Xemnas as a fail-safe, in case Sora turned out to be useless,
-blah, blah, blah, we all get it now. Spoilers really are lame. That report mentioned above is also very interesting...But I
-still don't see how the "Repliku" or whatever could have joined the Organization. I could see why they would be called "special
-nobodies" though, as clones they aren't meant to exist, but still, I really don't think he could have been a member because he
-had a heart, though it was fake. As mentioned by Larxene, "She(Namine)broke his heart...More like smashed it, really." Not only
-that, but they would have added an "X" to his name, if he was truly meant to be a member. Sorry for the lecture, I'm sure it's
-annoying to read right now, but I'm only trying to make a point here. The Replica Project could also imply experiments with such
-beings used for the Organization for different purposes of the members and their own seperate, individual goals. Finally, Xion
-was, more than likely, made before the Riku Replica and the events of Castle Oblivion.
-{{KrytenKoro|We don't know if they added an x to his name, because we never got an actual name for him.
-Even if he had a fake heart, the report makes him out to be the same basic thing as Xion, so whatever applies to her should pretty much apply to him.
-I thought he clearly absorbed Zexion, because he was trying to "gain powers the real Riku doesn't have".}}
-That's true, he did absorb Zexion's life force to become stronger than the real Riku. And we don't know whether or not an "x"
-was added.  All I'm trying to say is, we can't be sure to classify him as No.2 in the project without Xemnas' supervision. In
-COM, it seemed Xemnas was clearly not involved, and remember who created the Riku Replica! We'll
-just have to wait for the game and see for ourselves.
-==Template==
-{{Template:ST|time=19:04, November 7, 2009 (UTC)|text=Seeing that we now have four non-human species known to us (Heartless, Nobody, Unversed, Replica) think we should have a template for them?}}
-{{NinjaSheik|text=A template? Hmm...}}
-==Wait a minute==
-How do we know that all replicas fade into darkness except Xon. wouldn't it be just as accurate as saying all replicas crystallize except Repliku. shouldn't we say something  like "they disappear into an element they are afillated with"[[User:Shimu13|Shimu13]] 20:00, December 21, 2009 (UTC)
-==Anti-Form Replica==
-Isn't the replicas that Vexen make in his data and Absent Silhouette battle the same type of Replica from this article?--[[User:Xabryn|Xabryn]] 21:17, April 18, 2010 (UTC)
-Two months and yet no answers--[[User:Xabryn|Xabryn]] 01:55, June 19, 2010 (UTC)
-Yet no answers, I guess no one knows the answer--[[User:Xabryn|Xabryn]] 16:42, September 21, 2010 (UTC)
-You mean the data battle is a replica? I always thought of them as some kind of datas only [[User:17master|17master]] 16:57, September 21, 2010 (UTC)
-No, in the battle against Vexen he creates a replica of Sora in anti form I was thinking that the replicas made by him were the same replicas that we mention in this article--[[User:Xabryn|Xabryn]] 17:23, September 21, 2010 (UTC)
-I think it is, I mean, he collected Sora's data in the middle of the battle, and then created those Anti-Soras. So yeah, I think those are considered replicas since Vexen may have noticed the power of darkness inside Sora and decide to use that power instead of Sora's own power. Besides the Anti-Form is meant for battle, if he copied Sora, the replicas will have feelings of their own and they may turn against Vexen. [[User:17master|17master]] 17:31, September 21, 2010 (UTC)
-:They're called "Clone Soras". While it's possible that they are Replicas, there's no reason to believe so.[[User:KrytenKoro|<small>Glorious</small>]] [[User_talk:KrytenKoro|<small>CHAOS!</small>]] 17:35, September 21, 2010 (UTC)
-== Ice Colossus ==
-"[[Ice Colossus]] is a Replica of [[Ice Titan]] and is used as a boss along with Hades against [[Aqua]] in [[Kingdom Hearts Birth by Sleep]]."
-Is there any confirmation that this is the "R"eplica, or just a "r"eplica?[[Special:Contributions/24.13.125.86|24.13.125.86]] 04:56, May 20, 2010 (UTC)
-{{ZexionFan321|time=11:08, May 21, 2010 (UTC)|text=I think that they are the same but the Ice Colossus is just a mistranslation.}}
-:There's nothing to mistranslate, they couldn't possibly be mistranslations.[[User:KrytenKoro|<small>Glorious</small>]] [[User_talk:KrytenKoro|<small>CHAOS!</small>]] 18:45, May 21, 2010 (UTC)
-{{Organization 13|time=--Organization... XIV??! 21:27, May 21, 2010 (UTC)|text=Personally I think its Ice Colossus but there is a slim chance its a mistranslation. Heck, we thought it was "Unbirths" instead of "Unversed" for a while.}}
-It's NOT a mistranslation, "Ice Colossus" is spelled out ''in English'' right before its Arena battle. There is no vagueness about this.  --<span style="font-size:10pt">[[User:Neumannz|'''<span style="font-size=12pt; font-family:Gisha; color:#005400">Neumannz</span>''']], [[User talk:Neumannz|''<span style="color:black; font-family:Agency FB Bold">The Dark Falcon</span>'']]</span> 21:30, May 21, 2010 (UTC)
-And doesn't Hades call it inferior to the actual Ice Titan?--[[User:XYZach|XYZ.]] 01:38, June 19, 2010 (UTC)
-Does that make the Ice Collosus a nobody too? And when was it said that replicas were a special type of nobody?
-:1) That was Vexen, in one of the Secret Reports.
-:2) There's no reason to think that Ice Colossus is a "Replica", with a capital "R", especially since there was no Replica program at this time.
-:--<span style="font-size:10pt">[[User:Neumannz|'''<span style="font-size=12pt; font-family:Gisha; color:#005400">Neumannz</span>''']], [[User talk:Neumannz|''<span style="color:black; font-family:Agency FB Bold">The Dark Falcon</span>'']]</span> 16:16, July 5, 2010 (UTC)
-Okay then, but if heartless existed before the unversed naturally, doesn't that also mean that the nobodies would also occur naturally, I'm sure there would have been ppl ten yrs before Sora that had strong enough beings, the fallen from the keyblade war perhaps?
-:Well, sure, although technically that's speculation, but what does that have to do with the Ice Colossus?  --<span style="font-size:10pt">[[User:Neumannz|'''<span style="font-size=12pt; font-family:Gisha; color:#005400">Neumannz</span>''']], [[User talk:Neumannz|''<span style="color:black; font-family:Agency FB Bold">The Dark Falcon</span>'']]</span> 03:51, July 6, 2010 (UTC)
-I'm saying that if replicas are special nobodies and nobodies possibly existed way back when, then its possible that the Org. wasn't the first ones to make replicas, making it possible that Hades knew about nobodies and he created the Collosus or someone else created a replica, nobody, of the Ice Titan, but I guess since thats unknown it doesn't matter.
-==True shape==
-Here's something important: Secret report 23 states that the failed replica (repliku) was taken to C.O. But report 24 marks Sora's entrance to C.O., which happened almost simultaneously with Riku's entrance. The data collection by Vexen happened shortly afterwards. So, the replica was already considered a failure at least 1 day before the "Riku Data" where collected. Which means that, for a time, it was an identity-less replica. I think that means Replicas are not "Someone's Replica", but rather a replica attuned to copy someone later than its creation. Which leads to the question: How does a Replica look before copying someone's look? And, could this shape look anything like the Xion boss forms (the basic variation, the one only seen during mid-fight videos)? I, for one, am reminded of the word "puppet" when looking at this form.-Xhosant
-:It might just be a typo, but if it isn't, I think that they would look much like Xion did on Day 7.[[User:KrytenKoro|<small>Glorious</small>]] [[User_talk:KrytenKoro|<small>CHAOS!</small>]] 05:44, July 19, 2010 (UTC)
-== The? ==
-{{Xabryn|text=Is the "the" before Riku Replica really necessary? And if it is shouldn't it be before Xion too?}}
-I think it's because Riku Replica is a replica of a somebody and Xion is, well... replica that's made with memories without any base or some sort. [[User:17master|17master]] 17:16, September 21, 2010 (UTC)
-== No. i?? ==
-{{Dbdbz|time=22:05, November 30, 2010 (UTC)|text= Why does it say No. i??}}
-{{ST|text=because Xion is number i in the Replica Program, i being the imaginary number}}
-{{Dbdbz|time=22:24, November 30, 2010 (UTC)|text= Ohh ok thanks!!}}
-==I've==
 {{Bluer|01:02, 21 March 2008 (UTC)|I've seen the edit war in this page, kupo, and I'm not pleased. Someone please reorganize the Types section because I frankly have no idea how it is actually organized,}}
@@ Line 193: / Line 4: @@
 ==Emotions==
-I know its said many times throughout KH2 that nobodies have no emotions, but I feel like its an arguable fact. Yen Sid says it, and DiZ says it all the time, but the story seems to be trying to convince you otherwise. Roxas and Axel clearly actually care for eachother, otherwise Axel's actions make no sense. Namine is a Nobody, and yet she cares enough about Sora and Roxas to try to save them. Is it possible that these generalizations are just DiZ being sort of a "racist"?--[[User:Zephyrus11|Zephyrus11]] 08:42, 30 March 2008 (UTC)
+I know its said many times throughout KH2 that nobodies have no emotions, but I feel like its an arguable fact.  Yen Sid says it, and DiZ says it all the time, but the story seems to be trying to convince you otherwise.  Roxas and Axel clearly actually care for eachother, otherwise Axel's actions make no sense.  Namine is a Nobody, and yet she cares enough about Sora and Roxas to try to save them.  Is it possible that these generalizations are just DiZ being sort of a "racist"?--[[User:Zephyrus11|Zephyrus11]] 08:42, 30 March 2008 (UTC)
 :Not racist, but perhaps he was implying that since Nobody's are in actual bodies and souls without hearts, they would not have emotions. Yet sometimes I believe we don't need hearts to have emotion, memories could also trigger emotions. [[User:Bluerfn|[^_]][[User talk:Bluerfn|^]/]] 08:44, 30 March 2008 (UTC)
 ::Actually, it's a convertion screw-up. As I recall, it's only in the NA and EU version that it is actually directly stated in the story by charcters that Nobodies do not have emotions ''at all''. In the Jap version, they were merely called "incomplete", an did, to some extent, retain bits and pieces of emotions. At least that was the gist of it, I think. I'll try to find where I read that, just to be sure. --[[User:Hecko X|Hecko X]] 10:38, 30 March 2008 (UTC)
@@ Line 207: / Line 18: @@
 {{TNE|text=Heck, yeah, I guess he's referring to Days.}}
-definately talking about 365/2 days mission mode that would be cool though [[User:Pokhmon|Pokhmon]] 18:18, January 30, 2010 (UTC)
 ==Disney Characters==
@@ Line 223: / Line 32: @@
 :Can you show me?
-[[File:Land of Departure 01 (Removed) KHBBS.png]]
+[[image:Birth_by_Sleep_group_shot.jpg]]
 That's the picture that I mean. The three emblems on their uniforms resemble the nobody logo but upside down. [[User:Leiber_Mage]]
@@ Line 264: / Line 73: @@
 I regardless of that, I think that all Nobodies are Pureblood in that sense.}}
 {{KrytenKoro|Oh! Sorry. Yeah, Tiamat is generally the name of the ultimate evil dragon in the FF series, and seeing as almost all other Nobodies are named after FF jobs, either that or Bahamut would be a likely name for the thing.}}
-the differense between pure blood and emblem is artificiality, emblems are produced. in a sense because the first 6 of them were created using the same machine that turned them into heartless than they must artifical nobodies. in one of the ansem reports i remember him mentioning that the first emblem heartless were identicle to purebloods so he marked them. in the case of nobodys even thought they have an emblem it would appear are not marked to differentiate artifical from pure. the only other artificaly created Nobody is Roxas, who was created using the Dark key blade. in therory if Xemnas could have manipulated roxas or xion into recreating that key blade (if possible) than they would have been able to use it to artificialy create heartless and if those with strong hearts could be identified create nobodies as well.--[[User:Foutlet|Foutlet]] 18:08, November 10, 2009 (UTC)
 == Some thoughts on nobodies ==
@@ Line 279: / Line 86: @@
 {{Bro01|text=if the strong nobodies still have a human appearance, what crates the big ones like the twilight thorn? are they 'animal' nobodies or something?}}
-{{unbirthtalk|text=I think they're stronger than the common nobodies, but weaker than the human-like ones. To conserve its appearance when being a nobody, a person need to have a very powerful heart. If it's a bit less powerful,  the nobody will be strong but not human.}}
-== Special Nobodies ==
-I looked over the page pretty quick and saw a little info on this, but not enough. Are they created when someone willingly becomes a Heartless or when the original being and the Nobody exist at the same time? Please, enlighten me.
-Kthnxbai
---
-{{Unbirthtalk|text=If they're special, there's no normal way to them to appear. It's not the same for everyone, Roxas and Naminé are two different cases (as Naminé is, in essence, nothing).}}
-''== a question ==''
-{{Firaga44|text=i have a question do human nobodies since that don't exist wouldn't that mean that don't need to eat to survive i've been wonder that for a long time }}
-Larxene took a bite of meat (see Riku Replica's good luck charm). Coroxn-''The Lunar Brigade''
-{{EO|time=17:50, 19 August 2009 (UTC)|talktext=Nobodies are inexistent beings, the empty shells of those without hearts given life. Saying they are "without a heart" is a reference to a lack of a soul, which means it is assumed that they still possess the organ vital to human (Nobody) survival. It has never been official that human Nobodies like Xemnas eat, but it has been seen in the KH:CoM manga, something added merely for comic relief. Nobodies are, in a way, not human, so it should be assumed that they possess vital organs, but do not recquire the needs of an ordinary human to survive.}}
-{{firaga44|happy=kinda like the centiroins from dawn of the new world they consume mana naturally so they don't have to eat food ok they sound nothing alike i just wanted to bring that up}}
-== Somebodies ==
-Out of all of the fan terminology, people who refer to original beings as 'Somebodies' really, really pisses me off for some reason. I may be mistaken, but I cannot recall a single occurrence in which a Nobody said "Somebody", but not as some body, but as a being. Like a Heartless or Unversed. Is Somebody the actual cannon name for a regular person in the KH series? Please tell me it is not true.
-::No Nobody has ever mentioned their complete being, which should be the correct term ("Somebodies" is a shorter term for fanfiction writers, which is how it became popular), other than Roxas, who just called Sora his "Other", From what I know (I don't have a Psp so i can't play Birth By Sleep). I don't think it was ever mentioned in 358/2 days, it's beat around the bush. So it's more "Fanon." [[User:Animalbrad|animalbrad]] 06:34, April 12, 2010 (UTC)
-::Axel does in CoM. So, what's more annoying to me is people who'd rather complain than verify something themselves.[[User:KrytenKoro|<small>Glorious</small>]] [[User_talk:KrytenKoro|<small>CHAOS!</small>]] 07:57, April 12, 2010 (UTC)
-:::"Nobodies can't be somebodies."
-== Nobody Clothes? ==
-You know when Roxas became a Nobody he had different clothes to Sora? How is this? I always thought that a new Nobody would be naked at first, or at least have the same clothes as their complete beings.
-:Maybe Nobodies take the forms of their original selves, or in some cases, people whom their original selves have seen before. In that case, Sora meeting Ven. Ven's clothes are half Sora and half Roxas, as we'd call it. But because Roxas is half of Sora, well, that "half" was separated and we have... voila, clothes in a different style. That's what I think. '''[[User:Troisnyxetienne|<font color="black">TNÉ</font>]]''' <sub>'''[[User talk:Troisnyxetienne|<font color="#1E90FF">En avant</font>]] [[User:Troisnyxetienne/Mensa|<font color="#00BFFF ">Bravo !</font>]]'''</sub> 13:17, October 10, 2009 (UTC)
-== Somebodies... ==
-Has anyone noticed that of the organization's somebodies that we know what they look like are essentially identical to their nobodies while Roxas and Namine look fairly different (their hair)?
-::This is possibly because of Roxas and Namine's strange births. The Org. XIII Nobodies are literally the bodies of their Somebodies with minor changes due to the darkness. As Org. Nobodies were shells, and Roxas and Namine just appeared after Sora lost his heart, this is possibly why. Also, '''REMEMBER TO SIGN YOUR POSTS!''' - [[User:EternalNothingnessXIII|EternalNothingnessXIII]] 23:59, November 18, 2009 (UTC)
-Ahh this may be true! And sorry! --[[User:Webuiltthecross|Webuiltthecross]] 01:02, November 19, 2009 (UTC)
-== Aging ==
-{{HarpieSirenTalk|text= You've all seen the recent image of Ienzo. He looks prepubescent, while his Nobody is clearly in his late teens/early twenties. Not to mention Namine had an obvious growth spurt between CoM and KH2.  It looks like Nobodies can age. Of course, we'll probably need to play BBS before we have confirmation on this matter.
-ETA:And yes, while we don't know when Ienzo became a Nobody, that doesn't necessarily mean that it's true that Nobodies don't age. }}
-{{NitrousX|text=That scan of Ienzo is incrediby blurry, so his age can't be seen. Also, with Namine, I think they just altered her form to match Kairi's.}}
-{{HarpieSirenTalk|text= Okay, saw the interview. Which brings up even more questions than it answered. -_- BBS better explain this.}}
-What interview?--[[User:Masgrande|Masgrande]] 15:23, December 27, 2009 (UTC)
-== What the hell?! ==
-Why is half of this page a stub? What happened? [[Special:Contributions/68.190.210.240|68.190.210.240]] 03:48, January 20, 2010 (UTC)
-==Just a Thought   ==
-Since the heartless are like, always mass producing, does that mean that nobodies could be the same way, especially looking at all the dusks near the end of KH 2, so this got me wondering if there could be and other secret members of the Org. XIII. I mean XIII is just a number, besides,in the scene with Zexion and Xigbar gossiping about Xemnas, there was only 11 members but i believe it was still called Org. XIII yet they couldn't have absolutely known about Larxene and Roxas coming along. Unless Xemnas could see the future and saw his doom so he hid some members? Is it possible?
-([[User:Leviathan657|Leviathan657]] 03:27, February 6, 2010 (UTC))
-{{User:Xiggie/TalkTemplate
-|image=DaysDemyxHappy.png
-|imagesize=70px
-|color=dodgerblue
-|color2=black
-|border=blue
-|border2=black
-|textcolor=black
-|textcolor2=dodgerblue
-|fonttype=Trebuchet MS
-|name=BigHeadZack
-|sig=You shouldn't judge anyone by appearance.
-|time=If the subject fails to respond, use aggression to liberate his true disposition.
-|text=[[File:Nobody.png|15px]]Well, if you think back, a person must have a stong heart and a strong will for a nobody to be born. So, if Xemnas might have chosen to keep someone even more loyal then Saix to continue his plan. It is also possible that the Vexen clones could still be running around. Keep in mind I don't know if the clones were all killed or not.}}
-The current amount of games could MIGHT fit one new member in, but you have to remember that we have two more games left before KH3 (as was announced) and their them is going to be based on something else. My guess is that KH3 will probably be a battle between the original somebodies (as xehanort's heartless was destroyed before his nobody, he can come back), sora, and the hordes of heartless nododies etc. that still recognized xehanort as master.[[User:Oh,how the sea calls|Oh,how the sea calls]] 04:04, August 19, 2010 (UTC)
-== Nobodies in Birth by Sleep ==
-Scene the heartless appear in Birth by Sleep, it must have been possible for nobodies to exist in this time period too; also their could be humanoid nobodies that pre-dated Xemnas (just throwing that out there)
-:No. According to the mythology, only the strongest Heartless produce Nobodies when created. The body usually just fades away without the heart.[[User:KrytenKoro|<small>Glorious</small>]] [[User_talk:KrytenKoro|<small>CHAOS!</small>]] 03:14, February 7, 2010 (UTC)
-Ya, but you don't know if any strong-hearted persons turned into heartless; anyone could have.
-Can we get one thing clear? The Heartless from BBS are natural Heartless. Natural residents of the Realm of Darkness which never had anything to do with Xehanort. Which means, no Nobody ever existed. And even if they did, they would be wondering around the Realm of Nothingness for all eternity. Rucario 5:11, February 15, 2010
-Really where did you get that; I don't remember anything in Birth By Sleep explaining that those Heartless were not people who succumbed to the darkness in their hearts
-Well, maybe they were. Maybe they were people who somehow found their way into the Realm of Darkness and turned into Heartless. Rucario
-{{User:Xiggie/TalkTemplate
-|image=DaysDemyxHappy.png
-|imagesize=70px
-|color=dodgerblue
-|color2=black
-|border=blue
-|border2=black
-|textcolor=black
-|textcolor2=dodgerblue
-|fonttype=Trebuchet MS
-|name=BigHeadZack
-|sig=You shouldn't judge anyone by appearance.
-|time=If the subject fails to respond, use aggression to liberate his true disposition.
-|text=[[File:Nobody.png|15px]]Well, what if nobodies can only be created when an emblem heartless is born, or that Xehanort broke the chain of events that lead to the bodies being destroyed.}}
-== Locked? ==
-{{Dan da Man36|time=21:38, February 25, 2010 (UTC)|happy=Does this page still need to be locked so that only registered users can edit it? I've just noticed that it's been locked since March '08.}}
-==The third enemy = Nobody==
-{{TNE|time=01:05, May 18, 2010 (UTC)|text=This quote came from ASAS, KH's secret ending. Should I put it into the storyline of Kingdom Hearts, or the trivia, or what ? Chronologically, we know that they're the third enemy.}}
-== Replicas ==
-{{ST|text=Ok, so people have considered placing Replicas as a type of Nobody due to a comment by Vexen in a [[Secret Report]]. Question at hand: should the wiki consider Replicas as a type of Nobody? I for one think it is a very interesting concept.}}
-{{LapisScarab|time=00:53, July 1, 2010 (UTC)|text=If the game says that, sure, we should note it and make changes accordingly.}}
-{{ST|text=Okey-dokes will get straight to it}}
-== Where is the proof? ==
-There are several claims made about the nature of Nobodies that seem unfounded by the games alone. Some of them I have seen in Nomura interviews, but I have no idea where some of them come from. Specifically, the claim that all nobodies come from the world of like and end up in between or in the dark - the only birth places we know are for "special nobodies" there is no reference to the rest of them. There is a reference to finding Marluxia, but we have no idea where he was.
-I don't know the policy of this site, but I think there should be sources at the bottom.
-:Well, they are not beings of light nor darkness, so they have to be born in Realms In-Between, which make it either Twilight Town or Castle Oblivion. (I don't think this, however, would apply to Xehanort and his five accomplices.) Traverse Town is too close to the light, and TWTNW is just plain too close to the darkness. Kryten's been <s>studying</s> um, taking a close look at the interviews and the Final Mix logs (which have much more information than KH1 and KH2 combined), so I'm sure he'll be able to get it up and running. {{User:Troisnyxetienne/Signature}} 14:14, July 2, 2010 (UTC)
-== Confusion ==
-Why is Namine placed under the replica collumn, shouldn't she be in a special nobodies collumn or something along with the 5 absent sillhouettes? Also Anti-Saix was removed from the page, was this because he is non canon?
-Okay it was fixed so nvmd, though what exactly is Anti-Saix and the other Anit characters, I think Anti-Sora is a heartless, then theres an Anit form and Anti-Riku, could someone explain to me the antis?
-== Xemnas' Form(s)  ==
-Er...Where the Humaniod Nobodies are they have Marluxia's forms and Xion's forms, How come they don't have Xemnas' forms?[[User:SilverPinkKitty|SilverPinkKitty]] 22:11, July 7, 2010 (UTC)
-:Well, primarily for boss purposes. The lord of the castle gets the most powers. Marlulu was the lord of Castle Oblivion ; Xemnas is Teh Superi0r. It should be simple. {{User:Troisnyxetienne/Signature}} 23:53, July 7, 2010 (UTC)
-Ah...I see. Thank you for explaining ^_^[[User:SilverPinkKitty|SilverPinkKitty]] 04:07, July 8, 2010 (UTC)
-::The other forms should be there if Marluxia and Xion's are. They need to be added.[[User:KrytenKoro|<small>Glorious</small>]] [[User_talk:KrytenKoro|<small>CHAOS!</small>]] 10:15, July 8, 2010 (UTC)
-== Beta Reader? ==
-There's a few fine spots of bad or confusing grammar in this article... For example, looking at the trivia section, on the point about Heartless and Nobodies coming back together when they're destroyed, the second sentence reads "when a Nobody is destroyed before it's Heartless' other". It's actually meant to say "when a Nobody is destroyed before its corresponding Heartless". Can somebody go over this with a fine-toothed comb, please? [[Special:Contributions/82.37.246.236|82.37.246.236]] 17:33, July 23, 2010 (UTC)
-== Misnomer ==
-Shouldn't it be prudent to point out that in all actuallity, a Nobody should be called a Heartless, and vice-versa?
-:It kind of is, but it's basically because they appear as if they have no body - their body is actually having to fill the function of the heart as well, so it can't fill the function of the body as well as it should.[[User:KrytenKoro|<small>Glorious</small>]] [[User_talk:KrytenKoro|<small>CHAOS!</small>]] 19:08, August 1, 2010 (UTC)
-:: ^that was somewhat confusing but the point i'm trying to make is that a heartless is actually the 'heart' of that particular person, which means they 'technically' have no body (Nobody), whereas nobodies are the soul and body of a strong willed person whose heart has turned into a heartless, meaning that they have a 'body' (usually disfigured into one of the types we know) but not a heart, which make means they have no heart (heartless). Which means that they should technically have their opposites name, i'm not saying change it by any means, but to make a footnote or something about it. [[User:TheEncounter]]
-It is pretty ironic, but I don't know where that would be appropriate to note.{{User:LapisScarab/Sig}}22:32, August 1, 2010 (UTC)
-{{LyingMemories|time=[[User:Lying Memories|Lying Memories]] 23:27, August 1, 2010 (UTC)|luxord= I like to think of it this way. We've heard that the Heartless are those without hearts, because the hearts of the victims are trapped by the darkness that consumed them. So, in my opinion, the Heartless have hearts, but the darkness renders it incapable of performing it's functions, thus they are without hearts. And the Nobodies have the body and soul yes, but the body they have isn't one of the Realm of Light. So they don't have any bodies. That's my thought on it anyway}}
-== Naming ==
-It should be mentioned that the nobodies of strong will are named after their original selves. Each name is the letters of their complete self with an added x with the exception of Namine
-that;s already under the nature of the heart I believe.[[User:Oh,how the sea calls|Oh,how the sea calls]] 02:59, August 19, 2010 (UTC)
-That's only members of the Organiztion. It's something Xemnas came up with, not something naturally true to all Nobodies.{{User:LapisScarab/Sig}}03:21, August 19, 2010 (UTC)
-well it has been noted under the nature section, should i remove it? i mentioned it was an organization thing, but do i need to remove it?[[User:Oh,how the sea calls|Oh,how the sea calls]] 03:33, August 19, 2010 (UTC)
-Never mind, its under 'trivia'.[[User:Oh,how the sea calls|Oh,how the sea calls]] 03:40, August 19, 2010 (UTC)
-== RE Again:Aging? ==
-Should it be confirmed nobodies age I mean they do Namine does(from kh com to kh 2),Ienzo in bbs looks like a 9yr old kid but his nobody Zexion look's like a 19yr old man.The same for Axel and Saix in bbs they look like teen's in Kh2 there nobodies appear as grown men.It seem's nobodies do age and the reason the other's didnt is cause they where not in a adolesence state.Like the few seem to be kid's or teen's going threw adulthood then appear as grown men but since the other's where already above their teen's they didnt appear to change much but its just a theroie but Im most certain that now they age.--{{SUBST:User:Lssj4/sig2}} 03:35, October 17, 2010 (UTC)
-:Nomura specifically says that Nobodies don't age, even though Roxas and Namine clearly do. It is possible that they only grow because they are not true Nobodies, as they have some form of hearts.[[User:KrytenKoro|(ಠ_ೃ)]] [[User_talk:KrytenKoro|<small>Bully!</small>]] 06:14, October 17, 2010 (UTC)
-First off, where can we reference the idea of them not aging by Nomura? I haven't read or heard anything on this sight of such. Even if it is true, its possibly a mistranslation or a contradiction or even (considering everything in Kingdom Hearts is so complicated) that Nobodies grow but don't "age" in the sense of growing old and dying of age. Its possible they grow up to a certain age and then stop. Otherwise, there is no proper explanation for any of the above names given who are clearly younger then their nobodies, to have become heartless and develop nobodies within a year and age so much.
-:I'm aware this is an older post, but [http://forums.khinsider.com/handheld-entries/130181-latest-famitsu-interview-tetsuya-nomura.html this] is the interview where Nomura says Nobodies don't age.{{User:LapisScarab/Sig}}11:58, 13 July 2011 (EDT)
-== change ==
-they are not in coded, so the heart logo shouldn't be there!
-:His name is Roxas, by the way. [[User:Maggosh|mag]][[User talk:Maggosh|gosh]] 19:58, November 7, 2010 (UTC)
-==Emblem==
-The Nobody emblem was derived from the Mark of Mastery emblem Terra wore on his belt. [http://forums.khinsider.com/handheld-entries/147019-20-kh-mysteries-solved-sort.html Source].{{User:LapisScarab/Sig}}12:13, 13 July 2011 (EDT)
-== Recategorization ==
-*Do Absent Silhouettes grant experience towards Final Form? If so, I think they should be considered Nobodies.
-*Same question, with Replica Data.
-*Is there any indication that Data-Naminé and Data-Roxas are Nobodies, and not just data constructs?
-*Should Xemnas and Xion's different costumes really be listed here? We don't do that for other enemies (although Xion's each receive different enemy files).
-{{User:KrytenKoro/Sig}} 03:46, 14 March 2012 (UTC)
-<pre>
-File:Xemnas's Replica Data KHIIFM.png|'''[[Game:Xemnas|Xemnas's Replica Data]]'''
-File:Xigbar's Replica Data KHIIFM.png|'''[[Game:Xigbar|Xigbar's Replica Data]]'''
-File:Xaldin's Replica Data KHIIFM.png|'''[[Game:Xaldin|Xaldin's Replica Data]]'''
-File:Vexen's Replica Data KHIIFM.png|'''[[Game:Vexen|Vexen's Replica Data]]'''
-File:Lexaeus's Replica Data KHIIFM.png|'''[[Game:Lexaeus|Lexaeus's Replica Data]]'''
-File:Zexion's Replica Data KHIIFM.png|'''[[Game:Zexion|Zexion's Replica Data]]'''
-File:Saïx's Replica Data KHIIFM.png|'''[[Game:Saïx|Saïx's Replica Data]]'''
-File:Axel's Replica Data KHIIFM.png|'''[[Game:Axel|Axel's Replica Data]]'''
-File:Demyx's Replica Data KHIIFM.png|'''[[Game:Demyx|Demyx's Replica Data]]'''
-File:Luxord's Replica Data KHIIFM.png|'''[[Game:Luxord|Luxord's Replica Data]]'''
-File:Marluxia's Replica Data KHIIFM.png|'''[[Game:Marluxia|Marluxia's Replica Data]]'''
-File:Larxene's Replica Data KHIIFM.png|'''[[Game:Larxene|Larxene's Replica Data]]'''
-File:Roxas's Replica Data KHIIFM.png|'''[[Game:Roxas|Roxas's Replica Data]]'''
-File:Data-Naminé KHREC.png|[[Data-Naminé]]
-File:Data-Roxas KHREC.png|'''[[Game:Data-Roxas|??? (Roxas)]]'''
-File:Data-Roxas (Bugged) KHREC.png|'''[[Game:Data-Roxas|Bug Roxas]]'''
-File:Xemnas (Armored Controller) KHII.png|'''[[Game:Xemnas|Xemnas (Armored Controller)]]'''
-File:Xemnas (Final Form, Battle) KHII.png|'''[[Game:Xemnas|Xemnas (Final Form)]]'''
-File:Xion First Form KHD.png|'''[[Game:Xion|Xion First Form]]'''
-File:Xion Second Form KHD.png|'''[[Game:Xion|Xion Second Form]]'''
-File:Xion Third Form KHD.png|'''[[Game:Xion|Xion Third Form]]'''
-File:Xion Final Form KHD.png|'''[[Game:Xion|Xion Final Form]]'''
-</pre>
-== Does Anyone Know ==
-If Nobodies are statistically more likely to attack Sora than Heartless? I've always thought that they were doing that in Kingdom Hearts II, which would be a clever Easter Egg if true, because they're supposed to be smarter than Heartless.[[User:Neo Bahamut|Neo Bahamut]] ([[User talk:Neo Bahamut|talk]]) 02:01, 6 September 2013 (UTC)
-:I don't know that there's anything in the game that says so.{{User:KrytenKoro/Sig}} 05:11, 7 September 2013 (UTC)
-::The game itself doesn't say it, but my general observation when playing it was that bosses tended to use their attacks regardless of if anyone was in range, Heartless tended to seek out the closest person, & Nobodies tended to gang up on Sora. Some attacks, such as the Dancers' grappling move, I'm not sure I've ever even seen used on Donald, Goofy, or a world ally.[[User:Neo Bahamut|Neo Bahamut]] ([[User talk:Neo Bahamut|talk]]) 02:19, 8 September 2013 (UTC)
-== Riku Replica and Zexion ==
-I'm not sure it's fair to claim that RR slew Zexion ''by'' stealing his powers. Definitely we see that RR eliminates him in order to steal his powers, but saying he did it ''by'' absorbing his powers implies a method of murder that I'm not sure we see anywhere else. For example, when Xion was stealing Roxas and Sora's powers/memories, the game claims that would have only prevented Sora from waking, and put Roxas into a slumber -- not that it would eliminate them, as you would a Heartless and Nobody (which would presumably cause them to reawaken like Ienzo did, anyway, if Xion would eventually be slain herself).
-If there's any other instances of powers-stealing definitely killing someone, that would be relevant, but as it is, we know of at least one other Replica stealing powers while definitely not actually killing the victim.{{User:KrytenKoro/Sig}} 19:48, 20 January 2015 (UTC)
-::Axel tells the Riku Replica that he needs "the kind of power that the real Riku doesn't have." He then, referring to Zexion, says, "He's as good a place to start as any." This ''implies'' that Zexion is the source of the power the Riku Replica obtains to unlock skills such as Dark Aura during his second battle against Riku ("I thought that by finding some new strength, I could finally be someone, someone who's not at all you!"). Zexion does not die until the Riku Replica places a hand presumably around his throat. He glows, then Zexion does as he starts to fade, effectively dying. Are you trying to suggest Zexion was slain because his wounds just happened to overcome him at that point or because of a lack of oxygen? Implausible for ''Kingdom Hearts''. So naturally, based on what we can gather from the dialogue and cutscene, it is the absorption of Zexion's powers that kills Zexion. The only reason I changed the wording on the caption to not say "absorbed" is because it just seemed like an awkward word to use, because it sort of implies, to me, that the Riku Replica absorbed Zexion into his body like a sponge, which clearly does not happen. Honestly, why is this such a big deal? I can understand avoiding an edit war, but why is this an issue now? - {{User:EternalNothingnessXIII/Sig}} 02:20, 21 January 2015 (UTC)
-::I'm suggesting Riku Replica slew him, ''then'' absorbed his power -- similar to Sora vs. Roxas. As for the glowing? Riku already has dark powers. As far as I'm aware, we have no examples of "absorbing someone's power" killing them, while we have an example of another Replica absorbing someone's power and it only putting them to sleep.{{User:KrytenKoro/Sig}} 14:22, 21 January 2015 (UTC)
-:::Wait, how is Sora vs. Roxas anywhere similar to this? From my understanding, Sora's heart reacts to Memory's Skyscraper, drawing Roxas out. Roxas fights Sora within Sora's heart, and after losing, becomes content with not being the "dominant" existence between the two of them. If you refer to the scene when Roxas tells Sora to "look sharp" and Sora glows after Roxas is integrated back into him, that's different. I've always interpreted the glowing as an acquisition of new power, not the use of power to kill and then obtain new power. - {{User:EternalNothingnessXIII/Sig}} 18:15, 21 January 2015 (UTC)
-::::He's referring to Roxas and Xion in ''358/2 Days'', not Sora and Roxas in ''Kingdom Hearts II''. {{KeybladeSpyMaster/Sig}} 19:37, 21 January 2015 (UTC)
-:::::No, my second example was referring to Roxas vs. Sora. Certainly Roxas gained new powers by slaying Xion, but for Sora -- Roxas is subsumed, ''then'' Sora gains new powers (and in fairness, Roxas isn't even that subsumed). In the few instances of "taking other people's powers" we have, it doesn't actually kill them; if a "death" happens, it happens first, not simultaneously.{{User:KrytenKoro/Sig}} 20:13, 21 January 2015 (UTC)
-== Angel of Death and World of Nothingness ==
-As far as I know Specter is the only confirmed name of these non-journal Nobodies, while "Angel of Death" seems to be a fan term (technically it should also be the Specter, or "Marluxia (Third Form)") and "World of Nothingness" on the other hand is just mistaken for "Xemnas (Dragon Form)" because of the [[:KHWiki talk:Project_World#KHII|room's name]]. If anyone has other sources that can confirm one of these two names, please link it, otherwise I will change them accordingly to the Bradygames/Ultimania guidebook names. --{{User:ShardofTruth/Sig}} 09:38, 21 January 2015 (UTC)
-::Yes, these names really need to be changed. - {{User:EternalNothingnessXIII/Sig}} 18:12, 21 January 2015 (UTC)
-== Significance of Nobodies appearing in a world ==
-From the KHInsider interview: "Nomura: I want to make it so that you can tell who had come to that world by the enemies that appear there. I am thinking of the enemy types as a part of the total production this time."
-So, apparently the organization members leave Nobodies in their wake, at least for KH3. If we assume it is meant to apply to previous games, we infer that Roxas was at Hollow Bastion (poss. due to Sora?), Marluxia was at Kingdom of Corona, and at some point, the KH2 members toured through Twilight Town (excluding Xemnas), the Cavern of Remembrance, and the Underdrome, without us seeing them there.{{User:KrytenKoro/Sig}} 20:12, 4 January 2016 (UTC)
-== Silver Gummi ==
-Do we need to include the silver gummi from the Xemnas battle? If so, it would require us to make filler images for all the others like we do on the Dream Eater page.{{User:KrytenKoro/Sig}} 20:41, 31 January 2016 (UTC)
-==Things that I think should be changed==
-Why is Anti-Saix on here twice in two difference sections? I think he should only be in the Non-Canon section. --[[User:Elfdemon|Elfdemon]] ([[User talk:Elfdemon|talk]]) 00:01, 1 February 2016 (UTC)
-::Non-canon isn't a classification of type. We shouldn't even have that section.{{User:KrytenKoro/Sig}} 03:39, 1 February 2016 (UTC)
-Okay. <br/>
-Also, isn't Fake Vivi just a Dusk? So should that be removed from the page? --[[User:Elfdemon|Elfdemon]] ([[User talk:Elfdemon|talk]]) 05:04, 1 February 2016 (UTC)
-Yeah, Fake Vivi is a Dusk, but I'm not sure if should be removed from the page. Otherwise, by that logic, we might as well take Marluxia's Third Form and and Xenmas's Dragon off, too. Fake Vivi was just a Dusk in disguise, and Marluxia's and Xemnas's forms are just a different versions of the original.--{{User:NinjaSheik/Sig}} 22:55, 1 February 2016 (UTC)
-True, yeah, Fake Vivi should stay. Is the dragon Nobody Xemnas rides really a form of his? I always thought it was a separate Nobody. --[[User:Elfdemon|Elfdemon]] ([[User talk:Elfdemon|talk]]) 01:57, 2 February 2016 (UTC)
-:It's a separate Nobody, but it's name is "Xemnas (Dragon Form)".{{User:KrytenKoro/Sig}} 15:46, 2 February 2016 (UTC)
-Okay. --[[User:Elfdemon|Elfdemon]] ([[User talk:Elfdemon|talk]]) 02:01, 3 February 2016 (UTC)
-==Gummi Nobodies==
-Is the Core, Cruiser, and Mini Cruiser actually Gummi Nobodies? They have no Nobody Emblem on them anywhere. Pretty sure they are just structures built by Nobodies, much like The Castle That Never Was. Does it say in the game guide that they are Nobodies or something? --[[User:Elfdemon|Elfdemon]] ([[User talk:Elfdemon|talk]]) 03:07, 22 March 2016 (UTC)
-:Nevermind about the Cruisers and Mini Cruisers, those ''do'' have Nobody Emblems on them, but what about the Core? Also, I just looked at the game guide, and it does list them as enemies, but it doesn't say they are Nobodies. I find it really hard to believe that someone's leftover body turned into a Core or a Cruiser, seems like they are just structures. Could be wrong though. --[[User:Elfdemon|Elfdemon]] ([[User talk:Elfdemon|talk]]) 10:14, 23 March 2016 (UTC)
-:If Heartless can become ships, why not Nobodies? As for the Core, it's a piece of the entire Dreadnought, which definitely does have the emblem on it.{{User:KrytenKoro/Sig}} 12:56, 23 March 2016 (UTC)
-::I sort of meant the fact that the Core and Cruisers don't have eyes or a face, while basically every other Heartless and Nobody do. Honestly seems just like structure to me that have actual Nobodies inside of them. I could definitely be wrong though. I guess there's no way of really knowing for sure. --[[User:Elfdemon|Elfdemon]] ([[User talk:Elfdemon|talk]]) 13:56, 23 March 2016 (UTC)
-:::I can't see eyes or a face on any of the Gummi Nobodies. {{User:TheSilentHero/Sig}} 16:12, 23 March 2016 (UTC)
-::::I agree, they have some sort of central body part but calling it face is exaggerating it. The core also spots the Nobody emblem, you just can't see it in the Ultimania render because it's so small: [http://i.imgur.com/hsOgIh4.png] --{{User:ShardofTruth/Sig}} 18:49, 23 March 2016 (UTC)
-== Fake Vivi ==
-What qualifies fake vivi as a low-ranking rather than a special? Just because it was a dusk? It just looks strange next to the low-ranking nobodies.. {{User:Chainoffire/sig}} 05:34, 12 August 2017 (UTC)
-:That, and it's not explicitly stated to be high-ranking.{{User:KrytenKoro/Sig}} 18:58, 13 August 2017 (UTC)
-== Low-ranking Nobodies ==
-Is it correct to classify Twilight Thorn, Specter, Marulxia Third Form, and Xemnas' Dragon as lower-ranking Nobodies? - [[User:JTD95|JTD95]] ([[User talk:JTD95|talk]]) 00:10, 17 December 2017 (UTC)
-:Yhea, the High Rank Nobodies are the ones under the command of a certain Organization member and with a FF job class name:
-*Xemnas-Sorceror
-*Xigbar-Sniper
-*Xaldin-Dragoon
-*Vexen-Scholar (presumed)
-*Lexaeus-Monk (presumed)
-*Zexion-Blue Mage (Zexion's job class confirmed, Nobody never appeared)
-*Saix-Berserker
-*Axel-Assassin
-*Demyx-Dancer
-*Luxord-Gambler
-*Marluxia-Dark Knight (pretty much confirmed since we see them in KH3 trailer)
-*Larxene-Ninja (Larxene's job class confirmed, Nobody never appeared)
-*Roxas-Samurai
-*Xion-Mime (presumed)
---[[Special:Contributions/93.150.192.153|93.150.192.153]] 18:56, 17 December 2017 (UTC)
-::Ok, no. Since the wiki deals in only [[KHWiki:Manual_of_Style#Trivia|factual information]] (sourced in either games or interviews), that list won't be making it on the page. Especially those that are "presumed" or not in the games; that's just speculation. That said, I don't know where the determination for current lower-ranking Nobodies on the page comes from. Do we know if that's in an Ultimania or something? {{KeybladeSpyMaster/Sig}} 04:58, 18 December 2017 (UTC)
-:::I never say to create page of Nobodies that we never see, I just explained to JTD95 the differences between low and hig-ranking, the high-ranking are the Nobodies that are connected to a specific Organization member and have the name of the Job class related to that member, and I done the list of the job classes related to each member. The only ones that are actually confirmed are Larxene (that Nomura say she is Ninja job class), Zexion (where in a 358/2 Days interview he say each Organization member will have a fighting style related to the job class they are related, using Zexion as exemple refering to him to be a Blue Mage), and Marluxia, is pretty much confrimed from what we seen in the Kingdom Hearts III trailers. The others are obviusly only speculation, I never said to add them, for Blue Mage, Dark Knight and Ninja, too I suggest to wait instead of adding right now, since the actual existence of Blue Mage and Ninja we don't know, and Dark Knight... well... I presume you want to wait more information about the,.
-:::For the information about the high and low-rank Nobodies, was confirmed in both Journal and Ultimania (if I remember well)--[[Special:Contributions/93.150.192.153|93.150.192.153]] 10:30, 18 December 2017 (UTC)
-::::I would love to see sources for Blue Mage and Ninja. For Marluxia -- has anything actually called that a Dark Knight? Because with scythes and death-based spells, I'd think Necromancer would be much more likely.{{User:KrytenKoro/Sig}} 17:08, 22 December 2017 (UTC)
-:::::Off-topic, I always presumed Vexen and Lexaeus would be Defender (shields) and Viking (Axes). I'd think Zexion would make way more sense as Scholar (Books) or Illusionist (...illusion). Mime for Xion is a good pick, although I don't think she'd get any familiars.{{User:KrytenKoro/Sig}} 17:12, 22 December 2017 (UTC)
-::::::I ever thinked Marluxia is more likely a Dark Knight, since he have that ability of countdown, but who know. For Zexion, well... Nomura already confirmed he is a Blue Mage (even if yhea, the Illusionst and Scholar too are good for him), Vexen I doubt will be Defender since... we already have an Heartless with that name. For the confirmation, for Blue Mage I remember was made in a interview some time before 358's release, now find that will be pretty hard, but I remember because I hoped a lot to see the missing Nobidies in 358 in some way (and they don't do that... :( ) for Larxene I don't remember where was said... but I remember was quite common read that.--[[Special:Contributions/93.150.192.213|93.150.192.213]] 21:47, 22 December 2017 (UTC)
-== Terra's Mark ==
-I'm not seeing how the quote makes that clear.{{User:KrytenKoro/Sig}} 02:15, 8 January 2019 (UTC)
-:Sorry about that. Left out the important part (was multitasking and got distracted). Fixed now.--{{User:NinjaSheik/Sig}} 23:39, 9 January 2019 (UTC)
-== Replica Program ==
-This term is used multiple times in Days so it should be mentioned. To clarify, Xion, Riku Replica and Vexen's replicas are all part of the Replica Program? {{User:TheFifteenthMember/Sig1}} 00:42, 10 January 2019 (UTC)
-:Yessum. Probably the Replica Data, too.{{User:KrytenKoro/Sig}} 12:57, 10 January 2019 (UTC)
-==Kingdom Hearts III==
-In Kingdom Hearts III it is revealed that Xemnas, Ansem, Young Xehanort, Terra-Xehanort (?), and Dark Riku (Riku-Ansem?) are all in the present because their Hearts from the past were supplied Replica bodies. Roxas and Naminé also now reside in Replica bodies. Should they go under the replica section, or should it simply be mentioned somewhere? ([[User:Levi657|Levi657]] ([[User talk:Levi657|talk]]) 14:49, 7 February 2019 (UTC))
-:They have hearts, so they're not really nobodies.{{User:KrytenKoro/Sig}} 20:42, 7 February 2019 (UTC)
-::Terra-Xehanort is not a replice is the Terra true body possessed by a past MX. But the KH3 replicas are humans. They say Vexen now can create Replicas that are humans. Demyx say he was substitute by one of this replicas, and then this happen to Vexen too, so Dark Riku and KH3's Xion are the "human" replicas--[[Special:Contributions/93.150.192.195|93.150.192.195]] 21:00, 7 February 2019 (UTC)
-== KH3 Ultimania ==
-Not sure whether it would be interesting or not, but the Ultimania confirms that Roxas is no longer the only Nobody to return to being a person without being killed: Even did too.{{User:KrytenKoro/Sig}} 14:31, 4 March 2019 (UTC)
-:Strange. I kinda gotta wonder how. Please explain, Nomura. {{User:LightRoxas/Sig}} 02:01, 6 March 2019 (UTC)
-== Replicas on separate page ==
-I feel like with the expansion of replicas in III, it doesn't feel fitting to have them as a part of the Nobody page. Given that the replicas in III have hearts and are, as mentioned by the Organization, nearly indistinguishable from real people, they don't seem to fit under the Nobody umbrella anymore. {{User:LightRoxas/Sig}} 02:01, 6 March 2019 (UTC)
-:Agree. I don't think we should list them as Nobodies unless the Ultimania does.{{User:KrytenKoro/Sig}} 12:53, 6 March 2019 (UTC)
-::While on the topic of the Replicas, can we add the number of Replicas made to the page. Vexen states in his secret report that he made 20, which you can count out as Riku Replica, Xion, Xemnas, Ansem, Young Xehanort, Dark Riku, Xion 2.0, Roxas, and the 12 Xehanort Replicas. With that in mind, it seems Vexen simply improved on the already existing Replicas rather than creating new (unless I'm mistaken). ([[User:Levi657|Levi657]] ([[User talk:Levi657|talk]]) 13:51, 6 March 2019 (UTC))
-:::Dark Riku is explicitly one of the new top tier Replicas that he created since being re-recruited after Re:coded. That's why they use the vessel for Namine. Xion 2.0 would implicitly be one as well, though I don't remember if Roxas's vessel was supposed to be one of the fancy ones, or just whatever they could grab.{{User:KrytenKoro/Sig}} 15:14, 6 March 2019 (UTC)
-:::: I get that, I'm moreso wondering if the new replicas are just upgraded versions of the old ones or not. Otherwise it's extremely coincidental that there just so happens to have been 20 made by Vexen and we now know of 20. When Demyx refers to the old Replicas maybe he was only referring to the original Riku Replica and Xion, which were both destroyed went to the Realm of Darkness and Sora respectively. ([[User:Levi657|Levi657]] ([[User talk:Levi657|talk]]) 16:34, 6 March 2019 (UTC))
-I agree with Replicas getting their own page, though of course the ones that are referred to as Nobodys in Days should remain on here too. --[[User:Vanitas|Vanitas]] ([[User talk:Vanitas|talk]]) 18:11, 6 March 2019 (UTC)
-:FWIW: KH3 Ultimania enemy section lists Nobodies (including Xemnas who was pulled from time) with their emblem. Replicas (Xion, Dark Riku) have no emblem at all alongside their stats. Are we sure Vexen’s “could these Replicas not be classified as a special sort of Nobody” isn’t just a strange translation “liberty” taken by the English version? What’s the Japanese equivalent? ''[[User:Ultima Spark|<span style="color:#002395 ;">Ultima Spark</span>]]'' '''[[User talk:Ultima Spark|<span style="color:#007FFF ;">(talk)</span>]]''' [[File:Lofty Fantasy KH3D.png|17px]] 01:36, 7 March 2019 (UTC)
-少なくともこれらのレプリカについては、
-特別なノーバディと言っていいのではないか？
-It definitely calls them a type of Nobody. I mean, it uses that vague Nomura-speak, but it says it.{{User:KrytenKoro/Sig}} 02:39, 7 March 2019 (UTC)
-:It's still a little much to merge the two distinct concepts based on incommittial musing. The point of that line was that Replicas are like Nobodies in that they're bodies without hearts (initially), not that Replicas are the cast-off body when a person's heart becomes a Heartless. [[User:Pink Agaricus|Pink Agaricus]] ([[User talk:Pink Agaricus|talk]]) 06:19, 7 March 2019 (UTC)
-I'd say that if we are keeping them (Repliku/Xion) on the page we should put them under the Special Nobodies section, rather than having a Replica section. --[[User:Vanitas|Vanitas]] ([[User talk:Vanitas|talk]]) 10:41, 7 March 2019 (UTC)
-The KH3 Ultimania doesn't consider Xion, Dark Riku, or the Replica Xehanorts to be Nobodies. Xemnas is still considered a Nobody, so it's not because of the heart in Replica body situation. So maybe Replicas aren't Nobodies at all. {{User:TheSilentHero/Sig}} 16:37, 9 March 2019 (UTC)
-== Images ==
-I know we're still having this discussion in the forums for the larger policy, but using the KH3 pics leaves Vexen and Demyx without weapons, and leaves Xaldin, Lexaeus, and Zexion looking inconsistent.{{User:KrytenKoro/Sig}} 17:53, 18 March 2019 (UTC)
-::The only way around it I see to keep the Wiki consistent but up-to-date is to create another tab, "Real Organization XIII," and move the ''KHIII'' renders there. Either put the ''Days'' renders back under "Organization XIII" or simply leave the ones who do not appear in ''III'', but remove all the rest from that tab. - {{User:EternalNothingnessXIII/Sig}} 18:03, 18 March 2019 (UTC)
-:::I think we should keep it like this. The images may not all match together, but we should be using the latest images for those that have them, and "Real Organization XIII" is not a separate rank in Nobodies, so splitting them doesn't really make sense. {{User:TheSilentHero/Sig}} 18:52, 18 March 2019 (UTC)
-== Clone Sora ==
-Clone Sora is not a Nobody, I tried to defeat him with both the Final and Wisdom Form, he don't give EXP to neither of the two, if you don't belive me, I do that in a livestream.--[[Special:Contributions/93.41.38.64|93.41.38.64]] 12:35, 14 January 2020 (UTC)
-:It’s a special Nobody which you can only fight while fighting Vexen. It operates and is designed differently from regular Nobodies. - [[User:JTD95|JTD95]] ([[User talk:JTD95|talk]]) 17:44, 14 January 2020 (UTC)
-::I'd like to see OP's proof (please link); if they're right and it doesn't give Final EXP, then I say it shouldn't be classified as a Nobody (the same reason we classify the Experiment as a Heartless due to it giving Wisdom EXP, despite the Ultimania calling it an "other"). ''[[User:Ultima Spark|<span style="color:#002395 ;">Ultima Spark</span>]]'' '''[[User talk:Ultima Spark|<span style="color:#007FFF ;">(talk)</span>]]''' [[File:Lofty Fantasy KH3D.png|17px]] 18:22, 14 January 2020 (UTC)
-:::https://www.twitch.tv/videos/535429591
-::: 1: 21: 19 I show that is missing just 1 EXP for level up the Final Form, then I go to the Vexen's Absent Sillhouette, but when I kill the Sora Clone with the FF, it don't level up--[[Special:Contributions/93.41.38.64|93.41.38.64]] 19:49, 15 January 2020 (UTC)
-== Revisiting Replicas as Special Nobodies ==
-There is an earlier discussion in here about whether or not Replicas should be classified as Special Nobodies but an agreed on conclusion was not met, however the latest revision by [[User:Wikipirate]] on the [[Garden of Assemblage]] page (revision 837745) I believe brings this to attention again, as he made a point to list Replica enemies separately from Nobodies. Personally I agree with this, since as was discussed before, Xion and Dark Riku are not classified as Nobodies in the KH3 Ultimania, and the only reason they're classified as "special nobodies" on the wiki to begin with is because of the secret report by Vexen. However said secret report (in both EN and JP) is merely Vexen speculating that Replicas ''could'' be a special type of Nobody, not confirming that they actually are, meanwhile the more up-to-date KH3 Ultimania clearly does not give them the Nobody classification. My point is that Replicas should be listed separately from Nobodies on the wiki, and that the Replicas section on this page should either be removed and only mentioned in the See also section or only make mention of Vexen's speculation regarding their status. [[User:Pureautism|Pureautism]] ([[User talk:Pureautism|talk]]) 16:51, 15 February 2022 (UTC)
-:I agree. I think the main reason for calling Replicas Nobodies comes from 358/2 Days, where Xion is considered a Nobody (although that is for plot reasons, as they didn't know she was a replica). I don't think Xion is called a Nobody after that, and the KH3 Ultimania very clearly does not label the replicas as Nobodies. So I agree with splitting them.
-:On pages like the above-linked Garden of Assemblage, I don't think we need a separate section for replica enemies, though. They can just go in "Other". {{User:TheSilentHero/Sig}} 18:02, 15 February 2022 (UTC)