| Latest revision |
Your text |
| Line 19: |
Line 19: |
| @{{User:KrytenKoro/Sig}} and {{User:Neumannz/SigTemplate}} Hello? You still there?!?!?--[[Special:Contributions/98.198.221.97|98.198.221.97]] 19:45, 3 February 2019 (UTC) | | @{{User:KrytenKoro/Sig}} and {{User:Neumannz/SigTemplate}} Hello? You still there?!?!?--[[Special:Contributions/98.198.221.97|98.198.221.97]] 19:45, 3 February 2019 (UTC) |
| :Hello. Kryten and Neumannz might have missed this in the flood of edits on the recent changes list. Not sure I'm much help, but I'll try to explain. Citations are good to have in general, but mainly as another means of supporting the info we publish on here. Regarding the elapsed time, just because a certain amount of time has passed doesn't mean it is an automatic case-closed or no secondary support needed. Quite the contrary, sometimes it is these kind of citations that are used in later discussions. So, while it is somewhat an eyesore and may seem ridiculous, the citation is needed. {{User:Xion4ever/Sig}} 00:22, 4 February 2019 (UTC) | | :Hello. Kryten and Neumannz might have missed this in the flood of edits on the recent changes list. Not sure I'm much help, but I'll try to explain. Citations are good to have in general, but mainly as another means of supporting the info we publish on here. Regarding the elapsed time, just because a certain amount of time has passed doesn't mean it is an automatic case-closed or no secondary support needed. Quite the contrary, sometimes it is these kind of citations that are used in later discussions. So, while it is somewhat an eyesore and may seem ridiculous, the citation is needed. {{User:Xion4ever/Sig}} 00:22, 4 February 2019 (UTC) |
| ::Then again, you got the majority of the Disney characters in KH3 have their English voice actors listed and are fine without the "citation needed, as they ALL confirmed their roles in Social Media (e.g. Piotr Michael, Roger Craig Smith, Mick Wingert, Jared Butler etc..), yet some actors who normally don't have a social media account like Tom Kenny (Rabbit), Kelsey Lansdowne (Rapunzel), Leslie Miller (Tia Dalma) were easily that specific character and NO ONE Else.
| |
|
| |
| Agree to disagree, but Once again, I'm sorry but frankly it makes no sense to just wait 7+ years more so even longer to have the "citation needed" for Kevin Flynn, CLU and the Beagle Boy's English voice actors to have it on there when no other actor matches the character they played and not to mention that Fred doesn't use ANY form of Social media (e.g. Twitter) and the truth is the reason I removed the citation needed is just because It's been there for far to long and It just becomes a chore just having it idle when there is no update to the page whatsoever. Keep in mind this was before KH started to gain relevance through social media and before certain actors involved in the games confirmed their roles like some of the KH3 actors on social media sites like Twitter. Better to ask Fred's agency just like you guys did it with the other voice actors in DDD.--[[Special:Contributions/73.77.161.206|73.77.161.206]] 05:32, 5 February 2019 (UTC)
| |
| :There is no such thing as "too long". If the information doesn't exist, it doesn't exist.
| |
| :Also, Fred has a twitter account. I don't know where you're getting this idea he doesn't. [https://twitter.com/KrytenKoro/status/1095017615557357568 Here].{{User:KrytenKoro/Sig}} 17:59, 11 February 2019 (UTC)
| |
| ::"There is no such thing as "too long". If the information doesn't exist, it doesn't exist." - Yes there is, your just to blinded no fixated on it for 7+ years just to confirm if it's him when obviously it's his actor, secondly as I said before which you continue to ignore this none of the actors at the time DDD came out none of the voice actors involved didn't have them announced: "Hey I'm this character in that game" because at the time it didn't garner the attention and momentum that the later games have which is why you went on a scavenger hunt just asking the actors from DDD if they voiced this character. This is different cause as during HD 2.5, II.8 and especially KH3 their was no need to put in a "citation needed" and asking the English voice actors directly, as they ALL confirmed their roles in Social Media (e.g. Joe Ochman, Piotr Michael, Max Mittelman, Ray Chase, Roger Craig Smith, Mick Wingert, Jared Butler, Eliza Schneider etc..) because that's when KH got popular and momentum and I expect the same thing for the future KH titles for the specific actors involved in these titles.--[[Special:Contributions/73.77.161.206|73.77.161.206]] 20:20, 11 March 2019 (UTC)
| |
| ::"Also, Fred has a twitter account. I don't know where you're getting this idea he doesn't." Well because his first Twitter account was deleted after it remained inactive since 2013 after he stopped using it. So don't blame me for not noticing I just was unaware he created a new account. But fyi, sometimes actors might not respond to tweets either they aren't interested or because they aren't on twitter as often. So my best bet just ask the agency rather than wait a month more so years being fixated on getting the case closed already--[[Special:Contributions/73.77.161.206|73.77.161.206]] 20:20, 11 March 2019 (UTC)
| |
| :::Enough of this, you guys. Also, I should've brought this up earlier, but after DDD came out, I actively tried getting confirmation from all of the VAs who were not credited for their specific roles due to the confusion that sprouted because of false rumors and unreliable edits on IMDB. And yes, that included Mr. Tatasciore. For the record, I did contact his agency directly several times, but never got a response back.--{{User:NinjaSheik/Sig}} 20:32, 11 March 2019 (UTC)
| |
| ::::"Enough of this, you guys. Also, I should've brought this up earlier, but after DDD came out, I actively tried getting confirmation from all of the VAs who were not credited for their specific roles due to the confusion that sprouted because of false rumors and unreliable edits on IMDB. And yes, that included Mr. Tatasciore. For the record, I did contact his agency directly several times, but never got a response back." - Honestly Kryten and Ninja that is disingenuous, contemptuous bullshit. If you're not interested in having a good faith discussion, then why not just stop keeping the fucking "Citation Needed" ON EVERY page.
| |
| ::::Most of still are fixated on it for 7+ years just to confirm if it's him when obviously it's his actor, secondly as I said before which you continue to ignore this none of the actors at the time DDD came out none of the voice actors involved didn't have them announced: "Hey I'm this character in that game" because at the time it didn't garner the attention and momentum that the later games have which is why you went on a scavenger hunt just asking the actors from DDD if they voiced this character. This is different cause as during HD 2.5, II.8 and especially KH3 their was no need to put in a "citation needed" and asking the English voice actors directly, as they ALL confirmed their roles in Social Media (e.g. Joe Ochman, Piotr Michael, Max Mittelman, Ray Chase, Roger Craig Smith, Mick Wingert, Jared Butler, Eliza Schneider etc..) because that's when KH got popular and momentum and I expect the same thing for the future KH titles for the specific actors involved in these titles. I'm not interested in continuing this discussion even after you block my IP address since you've shown absolutely no argument and justification you're attempting to argue with.--[[Special:Contributions/73.77.161.206|73.77.161.206]] 22:13, 30 April 2019 (UTC)
| |
| :::::...in what way is Ninja stating that she tried to get formal confirmation from Tatasciore, and he neglected to respond, "disingenuous"? You demanded that we contact Tatasciore's agency, she informed you we already had. She's stating facts.
| |
| :::::"as I said before which you continue to ignore" -- no one ignored it, why are you claiming that? Just because that claim ''doesn't change the facts of the situation'' doesn't mean we're just ignoring you. You not getting your way != "everyone's being mean to you" or "they're not operating in good faith". Honestly, none of the accusations you've leveled against the editors involved in this discussion have followed from the actions you're responding to. NS is objectively discussing in good faith, informing you of the steps she's taken. So am I, by informing you of how wiki policy works. To be honest, you're the ''only'' one here engaging in bad faith, by consistently ignoring consensus policies, leveling personal accusations and insults, repeatedly misreporting the situation (ex: [https://twitter.com/lesliel_miller/status/1100490001727406080 Tia Dalma has very much been confirmed, on social media, by the actress], and as for rabbit and rapunzel, those weren't added by longstanding editors familiar with policy), and stridently refusing to respond to explanations of consensus policy.
| |
| :::::Wikis require verification. They do not allow people to just claim things that are "obvious", because doing so has a terrible track record. We're not trying to get the man's pay rescinded or something -- the article is literally just stating that there is a lack of a formal citation. Which...is true. That's an objectively true thing. I don't get why you're so fixated on removing that objectively true statement "because it's been seven years". Citations that meet wiki policy don't just crystallize on their own, ex nihilo, over the course of years -- either an editor has managed to acquire a suitable citation, or they haven't. It's pretty black-and-white, and its the requirement on wikipedia too.
| |
| :::::Seriously, it's innocuous maintenance markup. Why are you treating it with the same level of outrage as a personal insult to your lineage and name?{{User:KrytenKoro/Sig}} 12:49, 1 May 2019 (UTC)
| |
