53,710
edits
Talk:Kingdom Hearts Wiki: Difference between revisions
→Extra worlds?
KrytenKoro (talk | contribs) |
|||
| Line 634: | Line 634: | ||
#How's that? | #How's that? | ||
As for OR, how about you provide a source stating that it is allowed on this Wiki? Genertally Wikipedia's also apply to other Wikis. What allows this Wiki to have far more info on ''KH'' than Wikipedia is not the useage of OR, but the fact that since this Wiki is devoted to ''KH'' we are allowed to write "in-universe" and can go into far more into detail than would be considered encyclopedic on the main Wikipedia (for instance, seperate pages for all the ''KH'' worlds would not be allowed on thje main Wikipedia but are allowed here, allowing us to put a lot more info into them). [[User:Xerruy|Xerruy]] 12:37, July 26, 2010 (UTC) | As for OR, how about you provide a source stating that it is allowed on this Wiki? Genertally Wikipedia's also apply to other Wikis. What allows this Wiki to have far more info on ''KH'' than Wikipedia is not the useage of OR, but the fact that since this Wiki is devoted to ''KH'' we are allowed to write "in-universe" and can go into far more into detail than would be considered encyclopedic on the main Wikipedia (for instance, seperate pages for all the ''KH'' worlds would not be allowed on thje main Wikipedia but are allowed here, allowing us to put a lot more info into them). [[User:Xerruy|Xerruy]] 12:37, July 26, 2010 (UTC) | ||
Wow, this is a lot of mistakes. | |||
Re:Galexgan | |||
#The official, licensed guides each say that the Dive to the Heart is it's own world. Saying "Well, the official material could be completely wrong" is a terrible argument. | |||
#No, he does not make a point. Isla de Muerta is not sseparated, story wise, from "Port Royal". If I'm wrong on this, ''provide a source''. | |||
#I never said OR was prohibited. Also, you're calling me a liar because the citations I provide disagree with you, but you're so monumentally lazy that you refuse to look up any other citations yourself. Please shut up, and leave the discussion, because you are wasting everyone's time. | |||
#Please listen to what I said. CT is physically separate from HT, and is accessed through a wormhole from HT, just like TWTNW from Twilight Town, yes, they are both listed under Halloween Town planetoid, but you know full well that that is because they are from the same movie. | |||
#Again, if you are too lazy to follow my citations and look for it on your own, please shut up. | |||
Re:Xerruy | |||
#Ursula's Lair is canonically part of Atlantica, in every possible sense. It is not a valid analogy by any means. A better source would be Agrabah versus the Cave of Wonders, which are also treated as distinct in the games and movies (For example, the city areas have "Agrabah: Room name", and the CoW areas have "Cave of Wonders: Room name". As for your claim that "world areas are not listed as home worlds", yes, they definitely are. Anywhere that says "Hollow Bastion" uses a world area name, as does the articles where your edits were reverted. | |||
#It absolutely says CT is a separate place. They "go from Olympus Coliseum to the Underworld", they "go from Halloween Town to Christmas Town". | |||
#I have no idea what you are referring to when you just say "idem". Which reply are you referring to? | |||
#If you can't understand how it's faulty to use NYC and NYS as an analogy to Halloween Town being Halloween Town...wow. NYC IS NOT NYS, IT IS A SMALL PART OF NYS. Halloween Town is Halloween Town. There is no "Halloween Town State" nor "Halloween Town City", and neither the games nor movies have ever claimed there were. | |||
#Again, I provided multiple quotes from the game, and pointed you towards where more would be. | |||
#Do you understand what OR is? If this wiki banned OR, we would not be allowed to write ANYTHING that hadn't already been written in a reliable third party source, like the New York Times or an IGN article. We would not have any game stats, or list character's home worlds, or any of that, unless Professional Journalist Pete Penciller had already written it and had it published in major syndication.[[User:KrytenKoro|<small>Glorious</small>]] [[User_talk:KrytenKoro|<small>CHAOS!</small>]] 14:30, July 26, 2010 (UTC) | |||